Bagel Fair serves the best bagels in Indy. Don't forget they also serve bagel sandwiches that make for a great lunch! The breadth and quality of their bagels can only be matched in NYC!
1 - 10 of 11 reviews
Real bagels - competes with NY bagels, but maybe a bit heavier. Always fresh and warm. Lox spread could be better. We are lucky to have a source of very good bagels.
Bagel Fair has the best and the only real, fresh, New York bagels in Indy. If you like bagels you're going to Love Bagel Fair!
Bagel Fair has seasonal bagels. Near thanksgiving they have pumpkin bagels. Today they had Gingerbread bagels and they were delicious. Not sure how long they will be available. Probably not past the end of the month anyway.
I have only had bagels from the chains and grocery stores until now. Now I can say I've actually had a bagel. After seeing this place on the local TV station we stopped in and had a breakfast sandwich (superb), and got a bag of...More
These guys were doing bagels long before all the chains came to town and they are still the best. The bagels are thick and chewy. You'll get a sore jaw if you eat two of these bad boys but that is part of their goodness...More
I moved to Indy in 1975 and discovered Bagel Fair shortly thereafter. I had enjoyed real NYC bagels only once in my life and Bagel Fair was, and is, the real deal. Nothing else locally compares. I have delivered them by the dozens to out-of-town...More
I went to Bagel Fair several years ago but somehow forgot about the place until I just happen to be driving through Nora and remembered it. I plan on driving past this place many times in the coming weeks! The bagels are very different than...More
If you want traditional, made from scratch, fresh bagels in Indianapolis then this is the only place to go. As a transplant from the east coast, I have searched far and wide for real bagels in Indianapolis. Bagel Fair is the ONLY place that makes...More