Best food in all of Valley County, in the tiny town of Donnelly. It is a surprisingly international menu. Owners are very friendly. Make a reservation if it is a summer weekend.
1 - 10 of 64 reviews
The Buffalo Gal offers a diverse menu with a variety of flavor profiles. My favorite experience is eating outside at the picnic tables and picking food up from the window. This is a nice walk-up experience for gourmet food. It is also acceptable to sit...More
I extended our visit to the area to do 3 things. Take the chair to the top of Brundage( this time of year they only run Th-Sun😟), visit the Gold Fork Hot Springs( husband👎) and go to Buffalo Gal . Batting .333 Our dinner made...More
Dinner for four. Nice wine list and appetiErs are plentiful. We had polenta fries with rosemary. Gnocchi was very good, as was chicken pasta. Burger was reported to be just ok, as were chicken croquettes. Dessert menu looked good, but we didn't partake. Outside seating...More
Buffalo Gal in Donnelly, Idaho has an eclectic mix of excellent food. My husband had a Chana curry special, loaded with chickpeas and veggies. He also had the Japanese steak bites. I had the steamed clams in white wine sauce and spring rolls. Amazingly fresh...More
You will need reservations or call for take-out at the Buffalo Gal. You will not believe the quality of food at this little restaurant. It is truly the best. Staring with their Spring Rolls and homemade hummus to die for. I usually bug a pint...More
New menu every week. Very good chef. International as well as American. Upper end food, but inside is basic.
We were driving through this small town looking for a place to meet for dinner and we settled on the Buffalo Gal. What a great decision. Mushroom chorizo app was full on garlic awesomeness. The smoked chicken pasta was just spicy enough and full of...More
Buffalo Gal has an interesting varied menu with strong Asian influence. I really enjoy making a meal out of several appetizers. Occasionally some of the offerings have been too spicy, but overall an intimate, exception experience for the McCall area restaurant offerings.
The food was on the upper end, but we found the prices too high for the portion sizes. For two people who had two main courses, two glasses of wine and two beers in total the price was $100. I admit I'm new to the...More
Dear Kim, Thank you for your review, your input helps us provide better customer service. Our hours are Wed.-Sun. 5:00 to 9:00, this information as well as our menu can be found at BuffalogaIidaho.com and is posted outside our front door. We do close during...More