I visited the restaurant close to my hotel. But if I come back and This id the place to come back to. Super place. Wonderful staff. The seasoned tuna. The Best I ever have gotten
1 - 10 of 460 reviews
We visited this place last year and was looking forward to visiting again. Considering what the Florida Keys have been through recently (hurricane Irma) we were wondering if it would even be open. One arrival we were welcomed and given a choice of cocktails to...More
We do love to hear comments like this. And so glad you you enjoyed yourself
Very nice time here last night. Ate in the bar area where they serve pizza as well as the entire dinner menu. Laura, our server, was fantastic, as was Brian, our host. Pizza as good as you'll find anywhere in the keys. Great bar and...More
Great having you join us in our lounge.I'm glad you enjoyed your night.
Very enjoyable lunchtime menu and staff. Everyone seems to hustle to provide attentive service. From pasta to sandwiches, quite a variety.
Thank you for joining us.
Always frequented Old Tavernier when we lived in the Keys years ago. On a recent return visit, just had to go back and yes it is still the same - fabulous! We left with big smiles and highly recommend not missing this extensive menu sure...More
We went here for dinner and then went to McDonalds afterward. After asking around we've found that this place is "hit or miss," apparently we missed. Our order was partially wrong and what we did get right was unbelievably salty or just plain terrible. After...More
I am sorry your experience at old tavernier restaurant was not a pleasant one.As you can see most of our reviews are very positive.Please feel free to contact me for additional comments and conversation.
I had dinner here with a group of friends last week during a wreck diving trip. The food and drinks were excellent and the service was very good. I had the lobster thermidor and it was fantastic. Everyone else indicated that their dishes were equally...More
Thank you for joining us with your group at old tavernier restaurant.
From the time you walk in to the time you leave, you feel the warmth and pride Old Tavernier takes in treating you as their guest. The Moscow Oysters are the favorite of ours. The fish is always fresh and yummy and the steak always...More
As a couple, we prefer to cook at home on most occasions. Every once and a while we venture out for an "evening on the town" lol. EVERY time we come to Old Tav, it's beyond enjoyable! The service, the food and the ambiance are...More
We love when our guest choose us for their special times and memories. Thank you for dining with us and your comments.
Had such an amazing experience. Very nice and friendly stuff. Sam and Caroline was wonderful. The Chef is a real pro. Hands down the Best Yellowfin Tuna Steak I've ever had! The Old Tavernier is perfect spot for a quiet nice dinner with loved ones!!!
We appreciate your comments and thank you for dining with us.