Me and my like this place so much we went there three days in a row. The coffee ice cream,rum raisin and black cherry are all excellent choices. Service was quick and friendly.
1 - 10 of 850 reviews
We visited here based on TripAdvisor recommendations and weren't disappointed. Loads of choices of ice cream making it a tough choice. I went for the white chocolate raspberry in a waffle cone which was great. I'd a single scoop which was plenty. Don't miss it...More
We visited many different ice cream parlors during our visit and this one was our favorite! Great variety, affordable and great flavor. It is a popular spot and there is typically a line to order. It is well worth the wait, however!
This place has a wide selection of hand churned ice-cream. Friendly service, interesting to learn that it has been in Siesta Key for over 25 years and has an Amish background. Give yourself a treat on a hot Florida day!
We visit Siesta Key every fall, and Big Olaf is one of our annual traditions. The ice cream is fabulous - hand-churned on site. White Chocolate Raspberry Swirl is my favorite. Prices are a bit high - seem to go up every year - but...More
There were lots of choices, the prices were reasonable, and the ice cream delicious! We will definitely visit again on our next trip to Siesta Key.