We tried the gelato after reading the reviews. Ny Italian here and it was so so. It is def not authentic gelato, was way to creamy. Very pricey too!

Do not miss this for dessert . Limoncello, Chocolate, pistachio, are just a few to try. Sharing is a must!

The gelato was fairly good- I got the lemon. They let you taste prior to choosing the flavor. Kind of pricy, but hey it's gelato, what do you expect. I liked it better than the regular ice cream we went to.

Although the gelato selection is somewhat more limited than what we have in New Orleans, this is an excellent place to stop, especially if you bring children, after dinner. You can save money by eating somewhere other than St. Armands Circle, but this is a...More

Every Year I visit Setimi's for excellent Gelato. It's some of the best in the US. ITs a husband and wife team. Wife works the front (she is very nice) and the husband in the kitchen.

There was a line, worth the wait. Small gelato, two flavors, both great: pistachio & chocolate. What's to not like???

The Tiramisu gelato was good with strong coffee taste. The pistachio gelato was the good color (not that fake green too green color meaning colorant in it). But I did not think that they are doing the real gelato recipe. It was not creamy and...More

We fell in love with gelato when we were in Europe last year and now we look for places that serve it in the US. We were so happy to find this place on St. Armand's Circle. We made 2 visits while we were staying...More

We were coming here every night from Siesta Key for gelato. It is the best place around. Many choices and very clean. Our daughter's allergies rarely allow her to enjoy dessert out of home. This place was exceptional. Very caring and understanding staff. We also...More

If you don't like gelato you're just odd and need retraining in eating good stuff. And this is GOOD gelato which you can lap up while you watch people envy you.