We thought this would be a nice place on the water to eat dinner. The outside seating area was nice, plenty of fans to keep you cool. But the food wasn't very good at all or the drinks. We had the Ahi Tuna special and...More
1 - 10 of 1,004 reviews
Very cute atmosphere. 3 different food menus, but not confusing. One early bird with about 6 selections all reasonably priced. Then a (thank you from locals) summer menu with about 10 or more reduced items (20 to 40 %) I had almond crusted grouper for...More
Really enjoyed dinner. I think this was our 4th time eating here. Always great. Service great and very nice staff. Good job! We will see you again.
A comfortable place on the water. Food was was quite good and service better than average. Tables are a bit close together, but not overly so. Great water view.
Yesterday Turtle's hosted our aunt's 80th birthday luncheon. It was difficult finding the right venue because we were a group of 12 and wanted a private room, and most places had a minimum of 20 or more. Heidi at Turtle's offered us their upstairs room,...More
There may be a problem... I ordered a rum runner and it was so bad I had to send it back and opted for a Corona. My son's mac and cheese was terrible. Noodles were mush, cheese tasteless. The calamari must have been frozen instead...More
Opened in 1986, Turtle's has distinguished itself as one of the leading fine dining restaurants in the Sarasota area over the last 30 years. Located at 8875 Midnight Pass Road on Siesta Key, it offers a conventional Florida menu emphasizing fresh seafood, impeccable service, colorful...More
Every year we visit this restaurant and it has gone from very good, to good and now poor. The quality of the food on our last visit was below standard for the price charged. Seafood pasta dishes were heavy with very bland sauces. They even...More