Had a great meal and fantastic service here. The atmosphere was romantic. Will definitely be returning on our next trip to Sanibel.
1 - 10 of 1,287 reviews
Sophisticated, excellent food and service, beautifully-plated dishes, good wine list, What more could you want?
How disappointing. We have been coming here for years and I booked 30 days in advance. We were sat at a table at which one chair backed up to the kitchen door/area and my husband, who is 165 lbs. could NOT fit in the seat...More
What a great find! Wonderful food ( I ordered the gulf shrimp and grits) . The meal along with very attentive service made for a very memorable experience. Make sure you save room for the Espresso Brulee. I'm only sorry I had to share. BEST...More
It was a 45 min drive each way from our home in the Edison Historic District. And well worth the trip. We had reservations and secured a table facing the water with a perfect view of the sunset. Everything from the appetizers thru the finish...More
This was a great meal and nice experience with a beautiful view of the sunset. It was a bit on the expensive side, but not out of line with other less quality meals on the island. We plan on returning when we are back on...More
We went to the Mad Hatter during a recent stay in Captiva. The staff was wonderful. The food was outstanding!! The restaurant is very small, but cozy. The only drawback is they don't have a full liquor license. but we had wine instead. Both of...More
Really, meh. And if you calculate how expensive it was, I definitely won't go back. The menu is unimaginative, the food mediocre at best. What bugged me the most was that when the waitress comes to check up on you, instead of just asking "how's...More
The Mad Hatter is truly an experience! The food was extraordinary! I had spicy watermelon salad, tarragon triple tail, and espresso creme brûlée for dessert. This was one of the best meals I have EVER eaten! I ate the flower - couldn’t convince my husband...More
Beautiful little restaurant with an amazing view. Go at sunset and watch the sun set over the water. In addition to the amazing view the food is phenomenal. This was seriously one of the best meals I have ever had. It is not an inexpensive...More