We were looking forward to a piece of pie and were not disappointed. The pie was smooth and creamy with great taste.
1 - 10 of 862 reviews
Was the Key Lime pie slice the best in Key West? Yes, it was. But I was surprised to find that Sweet Pete's has apparently taken over this restaurant. There's nothing here about the story of what Marcus Lemonis did for this business and Tami...More
We tried multiple Key Lime pies while visiting Key West. We wanted to find the one shown on The Profit and finally found it. It is difficult to find because there are so many Key Lime pie stores in Key West. It was the most...More
Definitely recommend their Key Lime Pie! Try the extra tart for a true Key Lime taste. The staff was very friendly and helpful.
We stopped here after a lengthy HOT bike ride and watched in the open kitchen as pie was being prepared. It was fun to see the ladies hard and work so we could enjoy pure deliciousness!
This is by far the best key lime pie I have ever had the pleasure eating. I had both a single pie slice and the chocolate covered bar on a stick and i can speak for both- they were amazing. I have to eat gluten...More
This was our second favorite pie in the Keys. (you have to read another review for number 1) The shop is bright and fun and full of candies! Two in our party came in for ice cream, but the machine was down, but the pie...More
We stopped in for a sweet treat after walking all evening. Key Lime pie was delicious! We got the little individual pies because the crust is SO good. Some folks in our group also got the big ole chewy chocolate chip cookies along with a...More