Very friendly and professional service. The food is good but the Curry does not have much taste. The Shrimps are good but the sauce gets absorbed by the rice. It would better to serve the curry separately from the rice.
1 - 10 of 1,523 reviews
We went with two other couples. The service was excellent. All six people thoroughly enjoyed what they ordered. Lobster mac & cheese is the best in town. Instead of dessert, we all shared another order of lobster Mac and cheese. Sitting on the porch on...More
We've eaten here twice on our Key West trips, and we'll be back. It's about a 15-minute walk from Duval Street, in a neighborhood (near our guesthouse, actually). It's a dark, cozy, quaint little restaurant with friendly staff. The food is delicious. My husband had...More
We decided to try The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. after reading the reviews. It was a delightful dinner. We made a reservation for 6:15 and had no trouble parking across the street. We were seated right away and our waiter was very helpful and personable....More
Thank you for the lovely equally delightful review! Scot, Co-Owner, The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.
Ate at The Buoy last night and based on recommendations tried the Lobster Thermidorian with a small spinach salad. The salad was quite possibly best I have ever eaten and when lobster arrived, it kept the momentum. The sides were excellent, smashed potato’s and a...More
Thank you for your testimonial! It's been quite awhile since we've had a four syllable word in one of our reviews, and even longer since I've responded with a five syllable word.
After almost a month in Key West, I have found the Best Restaurant !! This eatery, a converted house, is physically unassuming. The porch is delightful for dinner in this friendly neighborhood. The menu is eclectic, with seafood specialties leading a delicious choice of appetizers...More
Looking at the outside you would never know how nice it is on the inside. Jay was my waiter and was fast and knew all about the drinks and food. Went for my birthday and would go back again. Had lobster thermador.
Thank you for the nice review and Happy Birthday! Looking a Jay on the outside you would never know how nice he is on the inside, too. Scot Co-Owner, The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.
Went here for our first night in Key West. Perfect to be away from the touristic Duval Street. Have an amazing menu with typical dishes and the food was great. Also nice wine list. But then the service.. wow! The best so far for us...More
Thank you very much! And, yes, Jay is very helpful. Even though he is shorter than the rest of the waitstaff, he has extra-long, simian-like arms and can reach things on high shelves the rest of us can't. Like to-go boxes and...well, I guess just...More
My husband and I ate here at the suggestion of our B&B. The food was excellent. Service was great. Scott the owner has a great collection of Star Wars memorabilia. He is clearly proud of his restaurant and spent much time discussing the origin of...More
Thank you for the review! We love that you love the little plates and we love you for loving the little plates. May the fork be with you! Scot, Co-Owner, The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.