Loved the mermaid platter! Manager and wait staff were excellent. Portions were generous. Warm atmosphere.
1 - 10 of 732 reviews
We got take out from here one night during our stay in Key Colony. My husband had chicken Parmesan-he said it was very good-big portions plus salad pasta and lots of delicious bread included. I got a veal dish-I had veal Capri -it was with...More
We were a party of 8. Everyone raved about the food. The fish was so fresh. Our server did not miss a beat. Just a fun evening in an excellent restaurant!
Had an amazing dinner. Service was great ! I had yellow tail snapper with a fine glass of wine. My server was very descent and knew exactly how to describe some of the foods there. Very nice young tall male with long hair.
Have visited the Inn many times and always have a great meal, whether we go for lunch or dinner. Thank you for being open on the 4th of July. Was surprised to see so many people having dinner. Best prices in Marathon for the amount...More
We come to visit family in key colony beach several times a year. We always come to the Key Colony Inn for lunch and dinner. Last night we had an amazing dinner. The steak imperial was cooked to perfection. The lobster and shrimp dish is...More
I don't know where to begin. The wait staff was unshaven, unshowered young men who just were not into their jobs. Conch fritters? Nope. More like a hushpuppy that a conch accidentally rubbed up against. Your dinner comes with a salad. Don't bother. A wedge...More
Ate there twice last week a sun day and Friday superb service great French onion soup and counk chowder had both sea food dish and prime rib best Ihave had in the south reasonable prices and a nice upper scale restaurant our go to dinnig...More