Great food and service. Waitressing staff was very considerate and the food was pub style food. All went well.
1 - 10 of 326 reviews
We started with Scottish beer (Innis & Gunn) and a French blended red wine (both delicious). Saturday lunch was busy, lots of locals, lots of happy chatter. Some people waited in the bar for a table, but not for long. The restaurant is well-run and...More
Our group of four had a fantastic meal at Penny Lane this week. I always expect a friendly reception at an Irish Pub, and that's what we got! We had a reservation and were warmly received and shown to a quiet table upstairs. Our waiter...More
I took my wife for her birthday dinner and we really enjoyed our meals. We started with the onion soup and some clam chowder and they were both great. Our entrees, her Cobb salad and my reuben sandwich were both delicious. It was my second...More
Drove to the local grocery store in Old Saybrook and ended up stopping for lunch at Penny Lane Pub. I ordered the Chicken Quesadilla and a side salad, and hubby ordered the Baby Back Ribs which came with a side salad and fries. Salads were...More
Had High hopes here. That was quickly dashed when I got my burger which I requested med and got way over done. My lunch partner ordered poached pear salad but couldn't eat the pears as they were off tasting. When I told the server all...More
Hi, I am very sorry to hear about your experience. I'd love some more information and know who the server was as well as date and time you were in. Would you mind sharing? Its my policy that if a guest does not like what...More
Had prime rib special...absolutely delicious as well as the sides Burgersand club sandwich also very good Attentive and friendly waitstaff
We have always enjoyed PLP - the ambience, friendliness, and good solid food. But something has changed and the food has gone up to 5 stars ⭐️ In my opinion. You can still get solid pub food like amazing burgers, club sandwiches and the like....More
This is simply an outstanding restaurant. Excellent food & service. I look forward to going back there the next time I am in the area. They (Alex) even took the time to assist me in getting my car started - jumped battery.
This is one of our favorite local places to eat. The food is great and the service is top notch. The woodwork at the bar is amazing. Try the onion rings.