Average pizza but cute spot inspired the movie so you really are going there for the experience. Specialty slices are better.
1 - 10 of 40 reviews
Being a Chicago Pizza snob I was greatly impressed by the pizza quality at Mystic Pizza! I'll be back when I'm back in the area and it's definitely worth the drive if it's out of your way!!
We dined at the 56 West Main Street, Mystic, CT location. It was better than anticipated! The restaurant was clean and spacious. The dinner salad and original pizza was delicious. A small pizza with dinner salads was more than enough for the two of us....More
Stopped for late lunch and drink. Never having heard of Mystic prior to our vacation, Mystic Pizza seemed like a good place to eat, even though we never saw the movie. The waitress was very nice, but made an error with my order. She did...More
Since moving to New England last month I have been craving a good, not fancy, traditional american style pizza. I took visiting family to Mystic and since we had the kid we decided on Mystic pizza. It's a casual restaurant with a bar. We sat...More
We had a nice family dinner. Have not been here in some time. It stays the same. Kids had pasta. Adults had different sandwiches which we had cut to share. Enjoyed. We had good service by Allison (or maybe it was Allisa). Good family spot....More
a large pizza place with an upstairs and downstairs dining area on both floors. good seating in booths and tables.very nice,friendly staff at all levels of service.very clean,including the rest rooms. some parking on street and in the back parking lot. Pizza is very good....More
I had a Caesar salad, and a slice of pepperoni pizza. Both were very good! The slice was large (more like 2 slices, it was so big!), and the crust was cooked just right. The individual Caesar salad was a generous size and very good....More