One of the best pizzas I've had. Soft crust with a crispy bottom. Doesn't get too soggy to eat. Lots of delicious cheeses. Meatball grinder was super.

This pizza shop was recommended to us, and we were very satisfied with good, classic pizza, and plan to get it again sometime.

The employees are nice and down-to-earth. They are helpful and make excellent food! Takes a little longer than most places, but the quality of the food is worth it!

Girl working the counter is very nice and friendly. If your dining in, she'll bring you placemats, silverware, cups, and anything else you may need. The food is reasonably priced and it tastes great! Only downside is it always take a long time...25-30 mins, so...More

Cheese/toppings of pizza are 99% of the time burned. I always want to give it "one more chance" cuz of the proximity and I always end up hitting myself.

I really liked this pizza the couple of times I have had it. My coworker makes it a "must-have-go-to" whenever we have luncheons or it's someone's birthday/milestone achieved. Really good pizza... They have varieties, as well as other Italian staples such as cannoli, rice pudding,...More

I enjoy newington pizza, it's not my favorite, but it's a good pie. However, I wonder how much they would save if they stopped give out rice pudding with every large pie ordered. I for one never eat it.

We go there very often for pizza, grinders or a salad. Great for a quick meal after a youth/school sports game.

I ordered 2 slices of pizza to go at this small family restaurant and was disappointed to discover that it was Greek style. Worse yet, the amount of cheese on the top was overwhelming and the crust, though crisp, had little flavor. Lastly, there was...More

Recently started giving Newington pizza another try after years of going to elm hill pizza. Newington pizza is affordable and the taste of the pizza is VERY good. There's just the right amount of sauce and best of all my kids love it.