I love this classic pub and stop by whenever I’m in town. The staff is friendly and efficient. The food is good and in the summer you have a great view overlooking the lake from the dinning room.
1 - 10 of 69 reviews
Interesting place to eat very busy both times we visited. Good view over a lake while eating, the staff were friendly and accommodating. Food was good and the portions very large.
...This place has a lot going for it. Outside Newton on a small lake in a rural setting. Some planting going on outside, pleasant enough inside, room for parties. A large bar with screens if that's what you are looking for. Restaurant with an attractive...More
Nice, comfortable pub and restaurant atmosphere. View of the lake makes it special. Good selection of beers on tap. Very friendly service. Good food...we tried the beef tapas skewers served with Asian slaw. Generous portions of nicely grilled beef tenderloin. Bbq wings were good, very...More
Driving the back roads of Sussex county NJ, the place looked interesting, and it was. We got to sit outside on a gorgeous deck, overlooking s small pond. Beer was quick and cold, ordered the Tavern salad and a bacon cheeseburger. Excellent food, excellent service,...More
We had dinner in this Tavern overlooking a beautiful lake. Sheridan's Restaurant & Tavern is where the locals go. It's nice and friendly; easy going; regulars greeted by name. The waitstaff was friendly and efficient. The food was good and plentiful. I had the chicken...More
Excellent pub atmosphere. Clean taps make for good beer. Great beer selection. Good for sitting at the bar or getting a table overlooking the lake.
Great service and food...dining area separate from bar, very friendly staff and very reasonable. Good place for families on a budget to get out for a meal