You will wind up waiting as there are only 11 tables. And it is very popular. So bring a book as the bar is too small so you will. E outside. Pizzas are thin and excellent. Other dishes are hit or miss. Excellent specials.
1 - 10 of 110 reviews
Got spaghetti and meatballs, and chicken piccata. Both average, but was more disappointed by something as simple to correct as they did not provide bread or rolls with the over priced spaghetti.More
I apologize that you were not happy with your dinning experience with us. We truly do try to provide excellent quality food for everyone all the time. Sorry you were not aware that we do offer warm bread, toasted garlic bread and toasted garlic bread...More
Great atmosphere and wish the pizza was better. Liked the thin crust but not real tasty. Will try again. Really like the interior. Very friendly staff.
Thanks so much for your recent visit to Pi Pizzeria. Please let us know how we can make your pizza better for you next time, on us! as we are happy to do it. Looking forward to you coming back and trying us again
Excellent menu all around. Fresh ingredients in every dish. The specials are always outstanding too! Oh yea and the BEST brick oven pizza on the plant for sure.
Hello Vincent, Thank you so much for your positive review! I'm glad that you notice and appreciate the top quality ingredients we use here at Pi Pizzeria. We look forward to seeing you again soon.
My husband and I tried to come here for lunch one day but we didn't realize that they close at 2:30 and had gotten there too late!! Thankfully someone did walk out of the restaurant and let us know and also told us that the...More
We have been coming here since it opened and actually before it opened...West Creek Cafe, Beach Plum and Upper Crust. We have enjoyed all these iterations. Pi is so much more than a pizzeria! We love their pizza but so do we love everything else!...More
We went to this restaurant last year… we kind of found it by driving by, as it is not in the downtown hub. We ate there last year and I recall enjoying it. This year we ordered a margarita pizza, and it did come out...More
Thank you for your suggestions and comments. On your next visit ask that your Margarita has light sauce and extra cheese we are always happy to accommodate. Or try our Classic Cheese Pizza as it does have less sauce and the cheese covers the whole...More
The girl in the front acts likes she is the hostess at a 5 star restaurant in Manhattan. I felt like she thought I should be grateful to eat there. You call in an order and get a pick up time and apparently you can't...More
I am truly sorry about your unpleasant experience. Thank you for providing us with the opportunity to be able to correct this. We all strive for kind and courteous service with prompt, realistic pick up times. Our restaurant and take-out can be quite busy at...More
Stopped by after a long day. Hungry. Needed a good meal. Sat at the bar. Bartender was great. Caprese and a large pizza with a cannoli for dessert. Happy campers all around. Service was prompt and efficient (and it was a Friday night in August)....More
So -if you hit PI on a good night - it can be great! However tonight was NOT that night. At 5:30 - Called in a small carryout order - was told my pick up time was 7:10... SERIOUSLY?!?!? Had the idea to order 2...More
Thank you for being a frequent customer, glad you enjoy our wonderful pizzas and salads. It's true that we have quite a lot of pizza orders especially in August, I can understand your frustration. Our guests place take-out orders all day and there was a...More