We went here because someone told my friend they served buffalo burgers not on the menu. They did and she loved it. I had fish tacos which were too salty. My dog was allowed to come inside! And for that it gets a better review...More
1 - 10 of 136 reviews
Buffalo Nickel is one of the last remaining original restaurnats left on the island. Its alittle out of the way, but they offer shuttle service if you dont want to take a long walk along the ocean. Wait staff is very friendly and welcoming! Food...More
If you want to eat away from tourist crowd and kick back where the locals go, give Buffalo Nicke a try. A phone call will send a van to pick you up at one of 2 convenient Avalon locations. Then it's a short 10 minute...More
Very good Mexican fare located next to the heliport about two miles away from the Avalon waterfront. Though they will provide a free shuttle if you call, we hiked in and rode out. The sidewalk along the road ends about a mile from the restaurant...More
We stopped here while waiting for our helicopter ride back to the mainland. We just had beers but the patrons seemed to enjoy their food and it did look good also. The service was rapid and the prices were low. This place is a little...More
This restaurant is located at pebbly beach next to the helicopter port. Very casual, typical Mexican food. Presented well, good service, lunch specials. I crowded, local restaurant. Call them and they will send a shuttle car to pick you up at the boat dock as...More
My first time there was due to my FREE B-day meal ~~~~~~ My cousin & I headed over on the Van Provided by Buffalo Nickle. Great meal .................... nice atmosphere
I live on the island, and this is a place the locals go - a nice walk out of town, with generous portions and friendly service. Monday pasta nights are especially popular.
We go to the Buffalo Nickel for its old time Catalina atmosphere, helicopter watching, and to be on the water... the food is secondary, but worthwhile enuf to spend time there, and their ice tea is brewed, NOT that powdery stuff, an important pt. for...More
Food portions quite good. Price reasonable. Fish and chips a bit too much batter and not much fish. Service a bit slow considering no one else was there. Waiters very friendly and flexible with dishes.