It was a beautiful October evening and we decided to take a group of 7 guests to O Sagitario restaurant in Maia. It is a 40 minute drive from Caloura over to the north of the Island and, on the way, we caught a spectacular...view of the sun, setting. The restaurant is next to the church and street parking is not a problem. The restaurant is owned by a large fish and shellfish merchant based on Sao Miguel so you can guarantee the fish is going to be of the best quality and freshness. Diners are encouraged to go first into the shop on the ground floor to have a look at the fish available then go upstairs to the restaurant which is on a terrace (part of which is covered) overlooking the classic Portuguese church. We had phoned earlier to make a reservation purely because of the size of our party and our table was ready for us. Tables, with paper covers, and the chairs are basic aluminium. A charming lady waited on our table, she couldn't have been more helpful, and we ordered fresh cheese and bread to eat while ordering the fish. The cheese arrived with a sweet jam and made a welcome change from the normal, minced pepper sauce. A gentleman arrived to remind us of the names of the fish we had seen in the shop and suggested a large platter of mixed grilled fish for us to share (clearly an easier option) but this wasn't what we wanted. There is a fine line between helpfulness and encouraging guests to loose control of the bill and the amount of food required! In the end several of us ordered Swordfish and others ordered individual fish. All the fish was simply grilled (the chef needs to take a little more care not to overcook it) and served with tasty boiled potatoes and fresh salad. The fish was very much enjoyed by all.
There is a good well priced wine list and to follow there are a few home made deserts in addition to the, all too-standard, manufactured ice cream novelty selection.
O Sagitario is a good choice if you want to try the freshest Azorean fish available.More