Came twice over our vacation and was not disappointed. Pasta was made fresh on site and the tiramisu was to die for. Check it out.
11 - 20 of 139 reviews
Start with authentic Northern Italian cooking from ACTUAL Italians, add in the charm of the owners and you've got one of the best places to eat on Isla! Only steps away from the hostel, so it's convenient and good... There are many places to choose...More
Great pizza and not too expensive, on the way back to Casa La Naranja / Poc Na so a common spot for backpackers and locals
I've been a few times so far, and it's fast becoming my favorite spot to eat. Today I had a Puccano (?) pizza topped with Gorgonzola cheese and red onion--what a treat! Every bite was heaven. I was solo, so I ordered the small--too much...More
The pizza here is delicious and a great value for the price, good wine and beer too. Great atmosphere, wall colors, and art. I like that they have a leave-one-take-one bookshelf. Very nice and helpful staff.
Came here for the beautiful woman Gloria who runs this place. She is truly a generous an beautiful business owner and is so gracious every time we visit. Crepes are so awesome! But she'll make you pretty much awesome Italian or Mexican! We're going back...More
We ate lunch at caffe italia and were very disappointed, the service was awfully slow, we order 2 dishes of pasta and pizza, the pasta was basic and was not coocked enough, the pizza was poor and not good, we relied on tripadvisor review and...More
My wife and I spend the winters on Isla and Caffe Italia is one of our favorite places to eat. We like everything about it... the food, the wait staff, the atmosphere, and the prices are very reasonable.