Guests have called out the Inn On Fifth for its elegant ambiance, with its marble features and stylish rooms often receiving high marks. The hotel's prime location on Fifth Avenue is a major draw for those looking to explore the area's dining and shopping venues. While the rooftop pool and fitness center add to its allure, the spa and certain room amenities have not met everyone's expectations. Service at the Inn is typically regarded as exemplary, though not without occasional inconsistencies. Despite its cleanliness and comfort, some visitors feel that the pricing doesn't always equate to value, pointing out hidden fees and less-impressive views in certain rooms.