We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Wake up to chickens crowing and walk down narrow streets with white picket fences. Walk to boat docks for water ferry or supplies. Small island. Take a book. Enjoy the separation from the hectic pace of life. Like the Florida Keys of 1960s. A colony...More
I did not stay overnight on the property, but we did dine there twice on our most recent trip to Green Turtle and the food and service is awesome. The island is loaded with great options for food and this is probably the best.
My wife and I just returned from a Christmas stay at New Plymouth.
It was a wonderful stay. Just like it was before. Wally is back and Vernel is back as chef.
Wally and Vernel were great hosts taking care of all of our needs...More
This site was recommended to me by a travel agent who went there several times a year. Wally made us feel at home. I heard he sold it recently. I hope the new owners give the same personal service. He made us feel like family....More
It's not just the Inn, it's the whole Island. And Wally and Patty DO make you feel right at home. An unimaginable place: no need for locks on the doors, gorgeous locals, tremendous food, great private (wink - wink) beaches. . .and at incredible prices....More