All Articles New Haven is a hidden coastal treasure

New Haven is a hidden coastal treasure

Lighthouse and adjacent Long Island Sound
Lighthouse Point Park
Laura Begley Bloom
By Laura Begley Bloom1 Aug 2021 9 minutes read

Now that summer is officially in full swing, our thoughts are turning to beach days, lobster rolls, and open-air arts festivals. For many New Yorkers, that means fighting the traffic on the Long Island Expressway to get to a certain string of towns out east. But if you’ve been following The WeekEnder, then you know that we are drawn to the unexpected. Welcome to New Haven County, which has everything you could ever want for a summer weekend — minus the crowds and the high prices.

There’s much more than meets the eye here. At the heart of it all is New Haven itself, which is famously home to Yale University, founded in 1701. This coastal Connecticut city is also an emerging hub for arts and culture with a thriving, globally inspired food scene. Stretching beyond the leafy urban center, you’ll find charming small towns like Guilford and Branford, plus hiking trails and lighthouses, breweries and kayaking.

Left: Karl Franz Williams outside the Anchor Spa; Right Roxanne J. Coady standing in front of bookshelves
Karl Franz Williams (L), Roxanne J. Coady (R)

This mix is what got Yale grad Karl Franz Williams to return to his collegiate roots and transform an historic New Haven dive bar into a cutting-edge cocktail lounge called The Anchor Spa. Karl is considered a cocktail heavyweight: His sexy Harlem speakeasy, 67 Orange Street, regularly makes it onto lists of the world’s best bars. His reaction when a friend told him he should open another cocktail bar...in New Haven? “I just don’t see it, bro.” But after spending more time here, he was sold. “The thing that surprised me was how much locals care about the quality of their food and drinks,” says Karl. “Plus, New Haven has a strong arts scene and when you get artists together they tend to inspire each other.”

This is from The WeekEnder series: local insider guides for new destinations a short drive from New York City, delivered to your inbox twice a month. Sign up here!

Another passionate resident is Roxanne J. Coady, whose RJ Julia Booksellers in nearby Madison is a regular stop for high-wattage authors on book promotion tours. What appealed to her: “The shoreline towns are old-school, with a sense of connection that many communities have lost,” she says. “And New Haven has all the things that you want in an urban environment: a diverse community, music, and a rhythm to this city that is pretty fabulous.”

Let’s explore.

-Laura Begley Bloom, New York's Senior WeekEnder Writer

Where to stay

King Suite living area with seating and dining area at The Blake Hotel
The Blake Hotel

A big part of the appeal of New Haven County is that you can stay (affordably) in New Haven itself and dip in and out of the neighboring towns, but there are also some charming inns and hotels nearby.

For Instagrammers: The Blake Hotel in New Haven

Tucked away off a bustling street in downtown New Haven is this sleek stay with a clean, industrial design. The rooftop bar and restaurant, High George, is a garden oasis with spectacular city views.

For history buffs: Graduate New Haven in New Haven

Just steps from Yale University, an 1894 hotel was updated in a thoughtful way to become the Graduate. The designers preserved historic details (checkered-tile floors, pressed-tin ceiling, century-old elevator) while bringing the property into the modern era.

Left: Lobby area with seating and book at The Study at Yale (L); Right: Exterior of Thimble Islands Bed & Breakfast and its waterfront
The Study at Yale (L), Thimble Islands Bed & Breakfast (R)

For bookworms: The Study at Yale in New Haven

This literary-themed hotel is set right in the heart of Yale’s Arts Campus. There’s a library of new, used, and rare books curated by The Strand in New York City, and each room has a comfy armchair that’s made for curling up with a good read.

For sweethearts: Thimble Islands Bed & Breakfast in Branford

This secluded waterfront inn is run by a pair of innkeepers who spoil their guests with home-cooked breakfasts and afternoon wine and cheese.

For families: Madison Beach Hotel in Madison

Everyone in your brood will love this beachfront resort where all the rooms have water views and a balcony; some even have fireplaces.

Where to eat

Dishes from Mamoun’s Falafel
Mamoun’s Falafel

Ask any local about New Haven’s food scene and they will wax poetic about the pizza, the ethnic cuisine, and even the things that were invented here — from the hamburger to the lollipop. So why is this city such a culinary hotspot? “New Haven is a place of creation and food and learning and trial. People try new things here all the time,” says Colin Caplan, an historian, architect, genealogist, author, and founder of the food tour company, Taste of New Haven. Here are the places not to miss (and keep reading for Colin’s insider take on New Haven’s pizza scene).

Best breakfast

Claire’s Corner Copia in New Haven

Chef Claire Criscuolo has been called “the Alice Waters of New Haven” and can still be found in the kitchen cooking up creative vegetarian and vegan dishes. Didn’t make it for breakfast? Lunch is top-notch, too.

Willoughby’s in New Haven

Coffee is taken as seriously in New Haven as it is in Seattle. The place to go is this micro-roaster, which has several locations in and around the city.

Lunchtime

Burger from Louis’ Lunch; Right: Quiche, bread, and ham from Bishop’s Farm Market and Winery
Louis’ Lunch (L), Bishop’s Farm Market and Winery (R)

Louis’ Lunch in New Haven

Other restaurants try to make the claim, but the Library of Congress has certified that this historic diner is the actual birthplace of the hamburger. Pro-tip: Lunch is in the name, but Louis’ is also a worthy destination after dark.

Atticus Bookstore & Cafe in New Haven

You don’t have to be a bookworm to appreciate this café with simple soups and sandwiches right near Yale.

Bishop’s Orchards in Guilford

Planning a picnic? Bishop’s has farm-fresh bites to go, plus bottles of (decent) locally made wine. You can also pick your own fruit.

Seafood shacks

Lobby by a fire at The Place
The Place

Lenny & Joe’s Fish Tale in Madison

The Connecticut shoreline is known for its hot buttered lobster rolls and this is the best spot to try them.

The Place in Guilford

Sit on logs under a tent at this open-air seasonal restaurant while the staff cooks your fish and lobster over an open-hearth fire.

New Haven’s pizza wars

Left: Colin Caplan standing next to a pizza and oven; White clam pizza from Zuppardi's Apizza
Colin Caplan (L), Zuppardi's Apizza (R)

Colin Caplan knows a thing or two about pizza. He’s the author of the book Pizza in New Haven, produced the film Pizza: A Love Story (which tells the tale of three spots in New Haven), and runs local tours that combine history and eating. One insider tip: Many restaurants in town have the word “apizza” (the original Neapolitan word for pizza) in their name, and you want to pronounce it correctly. It’s “AH-beets.” We got Colin to give us the download on five of the best New Haven locations.

Frank Pepe Pizzeria

“The fifth oldest continuously run pizzeria in the country is widely known for its white clam pie, which it invented and perfected over 70 years ago,” says Colin. “My favorite is the native tomato pie with freshly chopped Connecticut tomatoes on a white pie with mozzarella.”

Sally’s Apizza

“Sally’s was founded back in the day by Salvatore Consiglio, Frank Pepe’s nephew,” says Colin. “The pinnacle pie for me is the plain tomato with red sauce and garlic. That pie pulls out the original New Haven style flavor — it's all about the tomato and the crust.”

Modern Apizza

“At this historic pizzeria from 1934, people drool over the Italian Bomb, with three meats and four vegetables impossibly stacked so that you can still pick it up,” says Colin.

Zuppardi's Apizza

"A lot of pizza freaks say the white clam is better than Pepe’s: They crack the clams right on top and cook it with the juice,” says Colin.

Bar

“This new-kid-on-the-block has a brewery and a dance club on weekends,” says Colin. “They're known for their mashed potato bacon pizza and their one-of-a-kind creations served on Tuesdays.”

Global bites

Ramen bowl from Mecha Noodle Bar
Mecha Noodle Bar

Food Truck Paradise in New Haven

In the Long Wharf area, you’ll find an army of food trucks featuring bites from all over Mexico and South America.

Lalibela in New Haven

This excellent Ethiopian restaurant also has a food truck that roams around town.

Mamoun’s Falafel in New Haven

A stoner favorite known for its falafel and other Middle Eastern specialties, from shawarma to kebabs.

Mecha Noodle Bar in New Haven

Ramen has made a big comeback in New Haven and Mecha has cornered the market. You’ll also find other delicious Asian dishes, from Vietnamese pho to Sichuan cucumbers.

Left: Trucks lined up at the Food Truck Paradise; Right: Plate of food from Lalibela
Food Truck Paradise (L), Lalibela (R)

September in Bangkok in New Haven

In an old brick building with a patio, this high-end Thai restaurant serves creative twists on the classics (think Thai tacos).

Otaru in New Haven

Head to this Japanese restaurant, say “omakase,” and enjoy the chef’s special selection of the best sushi outside NYC.

Mezcal in Fair Haven

You’ll feel like you’re stepping into a taberna in Mexico, with mariachi every Thursday and a mean mole.

Nature Dinner on Miya’s Farm in Woodbridge

Now here’s an experience not to be missed: Seasonal dinners on the farm with chef Bun Lai, who used to run a celebrated local sushi restaurant.

Date night

Booths and tables in the Union League Cafe dining room
Union League Cafe

Union League Cafe in New Haven

This French restaurant has the old-world charm of a Parisian brasserie and dishes that are straight out of the Right Bank.

Olea in New Haven

The fact that chef Jacques Pepin (who lives nearby) is a regular at this Basque restaurant with tapas and wine pairings tells you everything.

Sweet treats

Left: ice cream cone from Ashley’s Ice Cream; pastry display case at Libby’s
Ashley’s Ice Cream (L), Libby’s (R)

Libby’s in New Haven

The oldest pastry shop in New Haven dates back to 1923 and is the quintessential Little Italy experience, with Italian ice, cannolis, and more.

Arethusa Farm in New Haven

It’s next-level ice cream at this shop that sources its ingredients from its prized cows located on a farm upstate.

Ashley’s Ice Cream in Guilford

This tried-and-true old-school homemade ice cream shop has locations all over the area.

Cocktails (and more)

The Anchor Spa exterior with cafe tables
The Anchor Spa

The Anchor Spa in New Haven

Mixologist Karl Franz Williams bought this bar that opened right after Prohibition and brought it back to life with his special blend of craft cocktails. The daiquiri-inspired “Yale Beats Harvard” is — for obvious reasons — a fan favorite. There’s also an accompanying menu of Caribbean-inspired bites; don’t miss the Sexy Wings.

The Owl Shop in New Haven

Look for cigar and craft cocktail pairings at this cigar and pipe store from 1934 where you can also listen to live music.

Ordinary in New Haven

New Haven’s oldest tavern makes creative cocktails that are topped with offbeat ingredients like cotton candy. There’s also a cocktail museum onsite.

Stony Creek Brewery in Branford

Set on the Branford River, this brewery has outdoor seating, yard games, food trucks, and live music.

New England Brewing Company in Woodbridge

It’s worth the detour to the suburb of Woodbridge for the seasonally inspired craft brews.

What to do

Thimble Islands surrounded by water
Thimble Islands

Outdoors

In and around New Haven, it's easy to get out and enjoy nature. Here’s where the locals go:

Lighthouse Point Park in New Haven

Swimming, nature trails, a bird sanctuary, and an antique carousel set on over 82 acres.

East Rock Park in New Haven

The park is home to a giant rock formation that was carved by a boulder. “I love to go hiking and running here,” says Karl Franz Williams, owner of the Anchor Spa.

Thimble Islands in Branford

You can explore these charming little islands with a cruise aboard the Sea Mist.

Sleeping Giant State Park in Hamden

A 1.5-mile scenic trail leads to a stone observation tower on the peak of Mt. Carmel with excellent views of Long Island Sound and the New Haven area.

Branford River Paddlesports in Branford

Enjoy a paddle and a brew at this boating and kayaking outfitter located next door to the Stony Creek Brewery.

Branford Point Beach in Branford

This picturesque beach overlooks Long Island Sound.

Branford Land Trust in Branford

You'll find miles of hiking trails and nature preserves here.

Hammonasset Beach State Park in Madison

The state’s largest shoreline park has beaches, boardwalks, walking trails, and more.

Arts & culture

Person standing in front of artwork at NXTHVN
NXTHVN

When you’re in the New Haven area, you meet people like Istvan B’Racz, a composer, pianist, and longtime faculty member at The Neighborhood Music School (which he also attended as a child). It goes without saying that Istvan appreciates this area’s cultural appeal. “Yale draws an international group of people and as a result, you get a really interesting blend of arts and culture and architecture,” he says. Here are just a few of the cultural highlights not to miss.

Yale University Art Gallery in New Haven

A world-class museum with pieces by all the heavy hitters, from Winslow Homer and Vincent van Gogh to Jean-Michel Basquiat and Damien Hirst. “It’s my favorite place to go in the whole wide world,” says Istvan. “I sit there in awe.”

Yale Center for British Art in New Haven

Istvan is also a fan of this museum with the largest collection of British art outside the United Kingdom.

NXTHVN in New Haven

Located in two former manufacturing plants, this art space is dedicated to accelerating the careers of the next generation and supporting artists and curators of color.

Left: Band playing outside at the Westville Music Bowl; Right: Istvan B’Racz playing piano
Westville Music Bowl (L), Istvan B’Racz (R)

RJ Julia Booksellers in Madison

For over 30 years, this bookshop has been beloved by both authors and the local community. “It’s our job to be the best bookstore on the planet and it’s the community’s job to support us by buying books here and not online,” says owner Roxanne J. Coady.

Westville Music Bowl in New Haven

Istvan is a fan of this music spot in an old tennis center that has shows on weekends. “It recently opened to rave reviews,” he says.

Henry Whitfield State Museum in Guilford

Get a glimpse of the New England of yesterday at this museum set in the oldest stone house in New England.

Weekend plans. Shared.

Laura Begley Bloom
Laura Begley Bloom is a travel expert and content strategist who writes for a wide range of magazines and websites and appears regularly on television outlets ranging from the Weather Channel to CNN. Journalism is part of Laura's heritage. Her great great grandfather was a Civil War correspondent for the Chicago Tribune. You can learn more about Laura on laurabegleybloom.com.