Yep, this place is a real mixed bag. On one hand there truly is amazing service - the front desk staff were professional and helpful. I loved the drink and the towel upon checking in. When our room wasn't ready (we were very early), they took our baggage easily and our room was ready fairly quickly.
The problem is that it's not truly a boutique hotel - it's close, but they are missing the final touches that make it "boutique" and therefore worth the extra cost. Our sheets had codes written on them in black felt marker (really?), the air conditioner was quite loud, the room was extremely dark (the decor is so dark!) and they forgot to replace our towels (although they were super nice about it). I really liked the beds - super comfy.
The thing that made me sad about this hotel was that I was in HAWAII and my room felt like it belonged in Chelsea, NYC. The lobby is SO DARK and cramped, and the rooms are dark and cramped as well. It's on a TROPICAL ISLAND! You would have no clue from the interior. Parts of the hotel do feel slick, but somehow it just feels a bit off. Our room was truly awful - I really regret not getting a nice room with an ocean view.
If it were up to me, I think I would stay elsewhere that felt more like Hawaii - after all, isn't that what we tourists want? But thank you Hotel Renew for being nice to us - the service really was fantastic.
Room Tip: Pay more for an ocean view. If you don't, you could end up with a room with a view of a parking...
See more room tips
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC