We returned to Eva Villa two years after we first visited, and it remains a lovely setting, peaceful and comfortable, in a quiet neighborhood above Wailea beaches and resorts. (From reading other reviews, it looks like many folks return here.) If you want peace and quiet, away from the "action", but only 5 minutes away, this is ideal. You have a practically private pool and hot tub (there are only 3 units), cooking facilities, and very nice accommodations. The hosts are most hospitable, not intrusive, but readily available for any questions or supplying other needs, including the delicious fruit/muffins in the refrigerator.
