Very quiet hotel, the beds were very comfortable. Thank you for the wonderful experience!!!

This hotel is very quiet and clean. It was a perfect choice for the event we were staying at. I had reserved a few rooms and emailed the property the week before asking them to change the names of the reservations to the people they had been staying in the rooms. They did this and were very gracious when we arrived.

Rooms are very basic, but have flat panel TV's and the beds are comfortable.

The pool and hot tub were great. Continental breakfast had hot, flavorful coffee and a good assortment of food.

For the rate, I found this property to be a good value.

The lobby is so warm and welcoming with comfortable chairs and a fireplace. I got precisely the room I wanted -- top floor and very quiet -- and check-in was so easy. Very conveniently located on the main highway, close to downtown Sturgeon Bay. Great beds, microwave, fridge, coffeemaker, and WiFi. And the price is great, too. I found the room to be a tad dusty in a couple of places, which is why I only gave this motel a Very Good overall rating.

We paid $144/night for a fireplace suite which was probably only worth max. $70/night and I was expecting $144/night amenities. The room was very outdated, oddly configured (looked nothing like the photos on the website), and the furniture and bedding were obviously worn . Also, the temperature could not be regulated in our room, the sitting/fireplace room was at least 5 degrees warmer than the bedroom with the air blasted and 2 fans running...and we NEVER turned the fireplace on! Most likely this was a function of being on the 2nd floor and close to the pool. The suites should be the best rooms in the hotel, but in fact our room was quite a disappointment. I don't mind paying good money for a nice room, which is why I booked here based on other's reviews and past stays with other AmericInn hotels, however this was not the case. In comparison, I paid $150/night in an Alaskan B&B this summer (during the high season) which was definitely worth the money. The AmericInn, Sturgeon Bay, wasn't even in the same playing field, but yet almost the same cost. It actually hurt when I had to check out and the front desk lady handed me the bill for ~$350 for 2 nights. She asked me about my stay and I told her I was disappointed for the various reasons. She looked at me and said.."sorry"...handed me the bill, and said "have a nice day". That about sums it up!