We have vacationed at the lodge nearly every year for the past 14 years. We have taken our children for family vacations and also taken romantic getaways for my husband and myself. Liberty Park has recently been nicely restored with a warm and traditionally 'old Door County' atmosphere. The new rooms are lovely! The lodge has always served us a nice continental breakfast with several kinds of juice, coffee and tea, doughnuts or other pastries, or bagels. The hostess/manager is wonderful, helpful and accommodating, able to guide us to a new Door County restaurant with a great menu, a fun activity, or a scenic hiking trail. The crackling fire in the lobby at night is cozy and a fine place to relax, read a book, do puzzles, play a board game, or just chat with family and friends. I would highly recommend Liberty Park for a vacation getaway. Just wonderful.

Wow, how have the mighty fallen. My husband and I used to love this old historic Lodge in the late 80s and early 90s when we visited, initially while on our honeymoon. It had a *beautiful* old room on the ground level, originally a ballroom; came replete with a knitting circle of ladies doing their knitting, in one visit. You could move your chairs around as you wished, play board games, and simply enjoy the smell of carefully waxed vintage floors. The rooms were vintage too and utterly charming, full of the character only truly historic properties have. The whole place had an aura of a forgotten time, and when visiting, we felt completely at home, ensconsed in the atmosphere of a by-gone age. Once we stayed in one of their quaint cottages on the lakeshore: honestly, you couldn't have invented this place, it was so perfect.
Our experience this year: what a shocker. The whole place has been RENOVATED within an inch of its life, in what should have been called a 'gut renovation'. Almost nothing remains of its original character; the ground level destroyed in a parcelling-out that seems intent only on enhancing revenue; balconies and fake gazebos added where they ought not to be; all of the original clapboarding removed and replaced; and all of the original windows removed, in favor of Pella no doubt-- talk about destroying the soul of a building!! Every inch has been altered, and NOT for the better. Can I get another witness to this? Does anyone remember Liberty Lodge before it was ruined??
The service was perfunctory, the breakfast risible in its meagre offerings. I've learned that the owner, not content with taking a beautiful historic property and reducing it to a footnote in Door County history, has sold all of the property across the Hwy to condo developers. So much for those lovely old cottages!
There's not justice in the world, esp. when vulgarians get a hold of these beautiful old places. My husband and I left early, sick to our stomach. It's really a tragedy, what this owner has done to this historic Inn. The sign ought to read: Historic Once, but No More.

Very neat and charming historic hotel. It is far away from chain hotels style. Rooms are well designed representing old Door County style.
Disadvantage - a little to close to the highway.

A beautiful and well maintained property. The room was large, light and airy with beautiful wood floors and nice bedding. The setting could not be lovelier or more serene. For a quiet and relaxing visit, this Lodge could not be beaten.

The continental breakfast isn't very extensive but more like we used to get several years ago. You can definitely eat enough to hold you over until lunch.

The staff was very pleasant and helpful. I would love to return.

Wish I could post pictures so that I could share some nice ones. Maybe I'll learn someday.