We were so impressed and surprised that such a treasure exsisted in Columbus Ohio and we didn't know til now! We had such a wonderful relaxing time. We had reserved the "cariage house"...(We'd love to have it for a month as a "summer home".) The breakfasts were the best, tasted great just enough and presentation was grand. Al & Allen are exceptional hosts. We would recommend and for sure return. I can't say enough about this wonderful secret.

I live in Westerville (just outside Columbus) and decided to take my husband on a date weekend in town where we would do only things we'd never done before. We stayed in the Early Room at the Garden Manor and were delighted with the experience. Al and Allen were friendly, knowledgeable, and hospitable, offering us wine when we arrived and any time we wanted it throughout the weekend. The house and garden were beautiful, and the breakfasts were some of the best we've ever had, especially the egg casserole! Being so close to so many things on our agenda was nice, and I'm sure that any time we want to "get away" without going away, we will stay here.

I had to relocate rather suddenly from Florida for my new job in Columbus and, fortunately, found the Garden Manor. My extended stay was truly a treat. I loved the breakfasts, the fantastic restored Victorian manor, the beautiful outdoor garden, the amiable and generous hosts, and the interesting fellow guests. The manor is very conveniently located and easy to access. I would recommend it to anyone!

Al and Allen, I also wish you the very best.

Two friends and I stayed in the guest house at the Garden Manor for one night while touring the Columbus area. When we knocked on the door and Al came to open it, you could distinctly hear all three of our jaws thud to the floor as we got our first glimpse of the interior.

Al gave us a gracious welcome, taking us through the main house and then over to the guest house. He invited us to come back to the main house for a glass of wine before we started our evening on the town. We accepted the offer and enjoyed ourselves immensely - to the point that we pushed off our trip to The Book Loft, which says a lot for three bibliophiles!

The guest house is a spectacularly cozy getaway spot. My two friends stayed in the bedroom and I camped out in the living room on a more-comfortable-than-expected air mattress. In the morning, we were fed a gourmet breakfast that left us groaning with too-full-but-very-happy stomachs.

The only negative about this place is the surrounding neighborhood but honestly, once you walk through the front door, you're transported to another world. Al and Allan have done an incredible job and I would recommend this hotel without hesitation to anyone looking for a beautiful, relaxing place to stay in Columbus.

As a side note, the garden between the main and guest houses would be stunning for a cozy wedding or special event.