My wife and two young children stayed here for three nights during our first visit to Montauk.

Montauk and the east end of Long Island is not anywhere near as nice as the beaches in New England.

This place is okay - nothing special - and is very expensive fir what it is. Rooms are small with two double beds that is not really good for families - I actually cannot think who a room with this configuration would be good for.

I would not return here with or without kids. I have no room cleanliness issues - the indoor pool left much to be desires - I would not permit my daughter to swim in it due to cleanliness issues. Many of the chairs around the outside pool were broken and not usable.

I do not understand the appeal. Go somewhere else if you are going to Montauk - Cape Cod, Block Island, Nantucket are all much better choices!

Reserved three rooms for one overnight for a quick off-season roadtrip to Montauk with family. Although the hotel seems pretty old, it is quaint in its own way. The rooms are quite large and have a patio or deck. If you want the view of the water, I suggest the upper level rooms as the lower rooms only had a view of bushes. We were in the main building, which was a bit of a maze to navigate. Staff was very friendly and helpful.

The location, design, and decor were just great. We all really enjoyed the hotel! I would defintely recommend to couples or families!

While the location can't be beat I think the management of this property needs to fine tune quite a few things. We rented three rooms and two were lovely; one was in the "cottage" and looked like an afterthought. You can't do much about the size and ceiling heights of rooms that were built that many years ago but bland white walls, white linens (mediocre, not high end) and basically no decor did nothing to help the room. Dinner that night at the restaurant was a joke. The waiter was pleasant but not very professional and the food was OK, nothing great. Service at the bar was OK but the same cocktail ordered by two different people, served by the same bartender, came in two completely different glasses. The pool was out of towels in the middle of the day and the lifeguard kept saying someone would bring more. This never happened despite at least ten people asking for towels. Couldn't she have called someone? All in all the Montauk Yacht Club has the makings of a great resort but falls very short, especially for in season prices.