I have now stayed at Pointe Venus on three seperate occasions (2005, 2008, and during May and June this year). I have stayed at many hotels around the main island of Mauritius. I cannot understand why the service standards at Pointe Venus are so appalling. The location is (so long as you are looking for town rather than beach) excellent, taking advantage of a historic location, an elevated position and a fine view of the lagoon, the reef beyond and a good part of the town below. Indeed sitting on the balcony of the room was a very enjoyable (although did have to ask the constantly strimming gardener to take his noisy machine elsewhere on a couple of occasions) part of the trip taking in the scenery during the day or the quiet relaxation of the night.
It is the way the services of the hotel are presented that seems to let it down badly.
The restaurant is in a fine location, with an overhanging roof to provide shade and shelter, but otherwise open to prove cool air on the hottest of days. The roof has been colonised by small birds and very large bees! The birds take advantage of the crumbs and scraps left on tables (and you might not even have finished your meal!) as their main source of food. No attempt is made by staff to shoo them away and no attempt is made to clear tables once meals are finished. So the scraps remain and the birds take over tables and parts of the restaurant.
Indeed the attitude of the staff is very worrying. It is as though they have been brought in to backfill for the proper staff. They demonstrate no particular standard nor suggest that they have been trained. Some days tables have condiments and other days they do not so you have to ask for them. Some days there are napkins on the tables and other days not. Coffee and tea at breakfast is a hot water flask next to some jars of instant coffee and boxes of tea bags. They will make real coffee for you but each time you have to ask, and yet in a 4* they should know their job is to offer coffee or tea to their guests. The menu was very limited and quite apalling - it could be undercooked and cold. Returned food took another 20 minutes to be re-heated. Two of us experienced severe gastro-enteritis while there and spent three days confined to bed to recover.
In other Mauritian hotels the restaurant staff are very attentive, ask what you want, tell you what is available, and do their best to assist. At Pointe Venus the restaurant staff do very little. They do their best to assist but appear to have been given no direction at all on how to welcome guests, how to seat them, when to offer them a menu, how to ensure their table is laid for their menu choice, how to present the food. Most times we got the distinct impression that we had surprised them by turning up at all! We found our own table. Some time later a photocopied menu would be handed to us. Our choices were then conveyed to the staff as they had little interest in finding out what we wanted (and that would not be difficult given that there were generally only 2 or 3 choices per course anyway). Most of the time the staff seemed to lean on the waiters station gossiping with each other or when bothered by guests requests disappear into the kitchen area for very long periods.
The beds were hard wooden boxes with mattresses that had lost their stuffing, their 'spring' had gone, and that was uncomfortable and caused bad backs.
The worst part was the smell in the rooms. It seems as though the foul drainage connects direct to a sewer and the dirt around the pipe connections is not attended to. Some basic cleaning with disinfectant would prove effective as an interim measure.
Overall hygiene appears not to be high on the agenda. The coiled up dead worm on the bottom of the swimming pool I saw on my first day was still there when I left several days later. The pool also has a black tide mark around the wall evidencing that, although the leaves and wind-blown debris might be scooped off every so often, the pool itself is not cleaned in any meaningful way.
All of the above may seem as though I am intent on doing a 'hatchet job' on Pointe Venus. Far from it. I like its location and feel that once it gets back to some basic standards of hygiene, service, and catering it could be the 4* hotel it seeks to be. A friend in Mauritius suggested that the problem is that this hotel is run by a tour company (Mauritours) and that they have no experience of or skills in managing hotels. That needs to change for, in the meantime, they are letting down the whole of Rodrigues, a beautiful paradise of an island with wonderful friendly people. They both deserve a lot more from the Pointe Venus Hotel.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC