“A great spacious inn, with parking. Staff very friendly. Near to the station, so NYC is under an hour away.”
It is a great inn, the rooms are large and bed was comfy. When we arrived (the inn only has the office staffed for a few hours, three days per week), our keys had not been left for us as agreed, so we needed to call the emergency number. After just 10-15 minutes the housekeeper arrived and showed us to room A3. It was made up, but a bit grubby. It was a large room with a soda, tv and mini kitchen area.
The following morning Marcia who runs the inn said we were supposed to be in A1, she was very sorry about the mix up, and said we were free to move room or stay in A3. We changed to A1 which was huge, with a separate lounge and kitchen. Fantastic value, we paid just under $800 for the week.
The rooms are cleaned daily during the week, but still manage to look grubby. We had to clean the bathroom (and even buy some sink and plug unblocker).
We would recommend, for the size of rooms, convenience, free wifi, and Montclair location, just don't expect Hilton standards.
They also offer long term rentals, and many guests I think were long termers, very friendly.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC