We booked for three nights and only stayed one. Usually, when that happens, something went dramatically wrong and the customers storm off in a huff. That definitely was not true in this instance.
To backtrack, we booked a three-night stay in the suite for Columbus Day weekend. However, after settling in, I noticed a musty smell that was really annoying. (We assumed it was from a recently lighted fire). An air freshener didn't help. So I asked the owner, Sarah, if it would be possible to move to a different room. She couldn't oblige, because the inn was full.
And this is when Sarah excelled. She offered to call around to see if another room could be found for the night. Consider for a moment that would have cost her a substantial amount of money. I refused, in part because her gesture was so grand. I also was hopeful that things would improve in the room.
They didn't, and the next morning, we informed her that we had to leave. She not only waived the remaining room fee, but after I wanted to purchase some preserves she had for sale, she gave them to me gratis.
What I can also say was that the breakfast was excellent, and the rooms we saw in the main house (the suite is next door) were charming. I assume our problem was a fluke, and if only for the experience of staying with Sarah, a most gracious hostess, you should definitely consider the Blue Hill Inn if you are in the area.

You are pampered here at the Inn. Sara is a wonderful Innkeeper with an attention to pampering: appetizers before dinner, sweets after dinner and all homemade! Dinners at the inn are better than the breakfast. Beds are a bit uncomfortable and the floors and stairs uneven but the hospitality is worth it. We got a granola/yogurt/banana bread/chocolate breakfast to go when we were leaving early for hiking and would miss breakfast. Nice touch. Inn is walking distance to arborvine restaurant. Great food but a bit pricey.

We had a great room and food. The Blue Hill Inn is grand - from the rooms to the service in the breakfast room. The room staff is invisible - our room was made up while we were at breakfast. The breakfast area is a grand restaurant for the evening meal.

Enjoyed meeting the host/owners and several of the other guests over wine and hors d'oeuvres. Attractive historic inn. Only two caveats- rooms in front of inn had a lot of traffic noise- also we were surprised to be charged $8 per glass of wine after having been "invited" to partake.