Here is my overview:
- Looks can be deceiving. The hotel exterior/lobby/pool area is gorgeous, but most of the rooms are horrendous. The basic rooms look like a bad motel room used on the set of an 80's murder movie. My room had spider webs everywhere, the door didn't lock and holes in the furniture.
(Note - After I voiced my concerns multiple times, I was upgraded to a "nicer" room (let's use that term loosely) without getting charged. (They wanted to charge me for complaining)
- The elevators were disgusting, trash and food crumbs everywhere. Don't expect them to work most of the time and when they do, the staff is usually using them to transport things so guests have to wait.
- The Continental breakfast is a joke. The person who thought of this should be fired. You basically get a basket with 1 croissant, 1 muffin, 1 bagel and a glass of water (Even if there's 6 people in your group). Everything else (including orange juice, coffee, etc. is extra cost)
- Valet is horrible. If you go down and want your car, you'll be waiting about a half hour, because they park ALL the cars (just the ones that aren't pretty enough to park infront of the hotel) over by and past lincoln road. So you end up waiting 20-30 minutes.
- Service was good, the people that shined were Ari (Concierge) and Conrad (Server at the restaurant by the pool) Both provided excellent service and were the nicest staff on the entire property.
Summary: Everything that I described in the mentions above were always met with "We're renovating" or "Hotel is modernizing".. my advice, start with the rooms. It's the rooms people will remember most, then service, then all the other minor details.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC
14 February 2012
Thank you for your extremely detailed review of your stay and evaluation of the property. I do apologize for the inconveniences you endured while we are still in our renovation phase. I encourage you to email shelborneguest@meninhotels.com the next time you are in Miami Beach so we can accommodate you with a true Shelborne South Beach experience and give you a special rate!
Report response as inappropriate
This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of TripAdvisor LLC