We stayed two weeks. Expedia offered a discount due to the length of our stay. The room was large and clean, facing an interior courtyard. On two nights we had noisy neighbors, but otherwise it was very quiet. The dishwasher did not work, but the kitchen was otherwise adequately equipped. A CONAD store by the train station made shopping cheap and easy. We cooked every single meal at the apartment, and consequently saved a a lot of money by avoiding expensive restaurants. The stovetop was not "American style", but we quickly figured out that the 3 o'clock position is "off" and the 4 o'clock position is "high". There was a toaster and corkscrew, along with wineglasses, plates, bowls, colander, knives etc. The tableware was not especially elegant but adequate. There is an American-style coffee maker that uses cone filters, which were impossible to find in the city (Italians drink espresso instead). So for our American coffee, we use two trimmed paper napkins as filters, and that worked fine.
Others have commented on the odd bathroom, with its poor drainage. Those comments are valid, but the bathroom was clean and otherwise modern. We simply learned to use the mat to mop the water into the drain once we had showered. The bathroom had heated water pipes that made it very convenient to dry hand-laundered clothes.
Others have commented on rude reception and poor service. We found those comments to be untrue. Reception, while not particularly friendly, was perfectly correct. As for poor service - this is a self-catered apartment. You are not paying for service, so do not expect it. The accommodation included two cleanings and linen changes a week. Do not expect anything else and you will not be disappointed.
A couple others have commented on insects. The only night we had mosquitoes (even in March) was the night we left the window open. Keep the window closed and you will not have a problem. There was one comment about ants. Yes, we saw a few. They were not terrible. We kept most of our food in the fridge to discourage them. A very minor thing, really.
The neighborhood is fine, but not fancy. We felt absolutely secure. Florence around the train station is certainly busy and it attracts its share of beggars and hustlers, but it is not at all unsafe. The apartment's location, five minutes' walk from the station, was far enough away so that not even that sort of activity was in evidence around the apartment.
We did not have a problem locating Hotel Alamanni, where we picked up the key. Look for the faded red flag just past the bus stop on the left. Show them your passport and pay the 25 euro cleaning fee per stay, and they hand you the key and a map. Very simple, really. The apartment is located about 100 meters further up the street.
We thought the value for money was very good and would gladly stay here again. Perfect for those looking to save money on restaurants. Bigger than typical European hotel rooms.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC