I've stayed at this hotel 6 times over the past 18 months, and I thought I had found a real gem. Everything was always "just so", prices were fixed (and reasonable), and the people running it (family-run hotel) were warm and helpful.
For this last stay in December (3rd week of December), I found that it all started to go wrong in the booking process. Calling and getting different prices from the same person manning the phone (ranging from 140GBP a night to 80GBP a night) was the first unpleasant experience. Since the prices quoted matched those of a Hilton in Central London, and somewhat protesting the inconsistent pricing, I booked the first few days of my holiday at the Hilton (internet and breakfast included). However, for my last few days, I had no choice but to stay at the Wimbledon given that my fiancee's family live close to it, and I was going to have a few late-night Christmas and New Year celebration evenings there.
When I moved to the hotel, I was unhappy that I had been put in a basement room which smelled like stale beer, was very cold, and the television could only be watched if you were standing up (even sitting on the bed, it was so high up that the image was completely distorted). Outside the room, the carpet was dirty, worn, and not even held down in some places. The walls were peeling, and the yellowy-brown lighting was more akin to a cheap bar than a place you'd want to spend the night. Once again, it wasn't what I was accustomed to at the hotel, and even less so considering that most of the other rooms were empty. And certainly a shock moving from the Hilton to this, at the same prices.
The next straw to hit the camel's back was the manager chasing me out the door one morning while I was running to catch the bus (which I almost missed because of him). The reason he was chasing me was to ask me for the key and payment because he thought I was checking out. I then informed him that, as per my reservation, I still had 3 days to go at the hotel, and wasn't going to check out just yet.
Unfortunately, whereas before I used to recommend this hotel to everyone I knew, it has now fallen into my Hotels to Avoid list
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC