I actually stay in a guest house elsewhere, but I have come to Shields every evening for over a month to swim in te ocean and enjoy a drink. So, take this review for what it is: a review of their beautiful beach and pool bar, complete with in-pool barstools. The happy hour prices and service are fantastic. They use real fruits in the daiquiris, and if you want a non-alcoholic smoothie, that's on the menu as well. All frozen drinks are 2-for-1 at Happy Hour, 5-7 PM, 7 days a week.
I like to swim daily, and the Shields Happy Hour made me a regular. Multiple security guards on duty made me feel that my belongings were safe while I took a swim.
My only issue so far: early this week, while the security guard stepped away for 5 minutes, one of the roving beach thieves stole my shoes.
I always order a drink, pull a chair up to the edge of the raised cement bar floor near the beach, take off my shoes, and leave leave them while I go for a vigorous swim in the ocean. I've done that without issue for over a month, but this time the hotel manager had pulled the security guard off his regular post to help move a palette of Red Stripe, and some observant thief saw his opportunity.
Okay, so the shoes were originally free, so I'll just charge this one to the game. Bottom line is, Shields does a great job 99.9% of the time, and hey, this is Jamaica. Stunning natural beauty, ridiculously nice swimming conditions, genuinely nice people everywhere, but a LOT of crime, both petty and otherwise.
I still go to Shields for my daily happy hour swim. By now I have gotten to know a few of the longer staying guests and we have nice conversations. By the way, this hotel serves a niche market of German tourists, all of them super nice. I hope this review was helpful.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC