I'm back from 10 days in Koh Samui. I stayed at the Beach Republic for 10 nights. It was just great. This is one of the best hotels I have ever been to.
The rooms are brand new, clean, tastefully decorated and huge. I had a suite: a big dining room with a kitchen corner fully equiped and could have cooked if I wanted to, but I preferred Thai cuisine ! The bedroom is also big, bed is huge and has a feather "over" mattress which makes you feel as if you were sleeping on a cloud. The bathroom had an Italian shower and a bathtub with whirling/bubble water. There was a terrace, with the same bathtu, plus lounge chairs and a table. Both the living room and the bedroom had big flat screen TVs and DVD players. You may "rent" for free DVDs at the reception, which is nice if it rains :)
The pool/restaurant area is very well designed. There are 2 pools, one with whirling water and one where you can swim a bit (it is not huge). The lounge chairs and day beds are placed so that you have a full view of the sea, which is very nice. The restaurant is half outside, half inside (but always open to the sea breeze). The food is very good and prices are average. The breakfast, which was included in the price, offers everything from thai food (noodles, rice, etc) to bacon, sausages, eggs, cereals, yogurts, bread, fresh fruit, juices, tea and coffee.
I tried the spa several times and since I'm not a fan of Thai massages (I prefer Ayurvedic massages), I would not be a good judge.
Two very nice attentions: you get free drinkable water every day in your room and Wi fi is free.
The staff is very sweet and joyful. Julie, the manager, takes very good care of the residents. She always replies to your queries and makes sure you are satisfied.
The only thing I didn't like was the fact that since the hotel opens its pool/restaurant area to non residents of the hotel, you often see groups of loud tourists come over and ... be loud ! I had my MP3 to overcome this, but it would be nicer if there was a "quietness politic", where residents cannot be annoyed by loud non residents. I understand that Sunday brunch is a institution in Lamai, and that Sunday afternoons may be skipped by residents (I went elsewhere on both Sundays), but for the rest of the week, it would be nice to have some peace and quiet :)
Except for that minor drawback, I had a wonderful time at the Beach Republic and would recommend it to anyone (except for elderly people who may not appreciate the music and DJ). I would go back without hesitation.
