We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox. Mac: Safari.

New York City

Free Newsletter

Interested in New York City?

We'll send you updates with the latest deals, reviews and articles for New York City each week.

New York City Forum: Just got back..........

Which New York City hotels are on sale?
See hotels
Montreal
posts: 211
reviews: 7
 Just got back.......... 

We arrived at the Port Authority early Friday am, and hailed a cab with ease, gave the taxi driver the hotel address/name, but I wasn't sure of the cross st. He refused to take us, and dropped us off around the corner, and asked for the $4. I refused to pay.

We then asked for assistance at a nearby hotel, took the subway(bought a metrocard)and arrived at the hotel in a very short time.

We were staying at the Hilton Garden Inn in Tribeca. I had the intention of simply checking in and storing the bags,(it was only 6am), but the desk clerk offered to check us in directly as there was an available room.(No extra charge) We got to shower and freshen up before getting on with day. The room itself was clean, nicely decorated, and of average size. The downside was an obstructed view, only got to see a brick wall. lol

We headed out for breakfast and decided to walk as the weather was gorgeous, but the lineup at Clinton St Bakery was enormous, and it would have made us late for our Graffiti Tour. So we ate some breakfast sandwiches at Think Coffee on Bleeker st, met our tour guide and went on our tour which was very interesting. We walked through the East Village/LES.

Next I visited the Tenement Museum, while the kids stocked up on candy at EconoCandy. I was able to get a ticket on the spot, and throughly enjoyed visiting the museum.

Then we were off to Broadway st for shopping. Tons of people, great people watching, beautiful buildings. Bought tacos from a truck vendor. Yummy. We walked all the way to Union Square, and ended the evening with dinner at Blue Water Grill. The food was amazing(sushi, swordfish, atlantic char), service wonderful, and attentive.Back to the hotel by taxi, as we were way too tired to take the subway.

On Saturday morning, we took the subway to the Brooklyn Flea Market, and had an amazing time time there. Between meeting so many friendly people, and eating delicious food, and getting some incredible finds........it was a successful day. I ate a Puposa with cheese and cod!!!!!!!!, as well as a Mac'Cheese Lobster roll!!!!! and for dessert.......a donut! The kids had the Porchetta sandwiches. Thanks TA and BrooklynMel for steering me in the right direction. That food was the best. We bought some one of a kind items, and some collectibles.

We had dinner reservations at Capital Grill,(Time Life Building) prix fixe.........good food, good service, but I found the atmosphere to be a bit stuffy.

We the headed off to Upright Citizen's Brigade on W 26th st, and was told there was only standing room only even though we booked the tickets in advance online. We left at intermission, as we were too tired to stand anymore. ( I prefer the venue at E 3rd st)

Last day, we decided to eat at Balthazar, before heading uptown. Way too expensive, $80 including tip for 3 plates of french toast and pancakes. I was not impressed.

We stored our luggage at the Port Authority, $8/bag.

Grand Central Terminal.......beautiful

When we got to the Sony Wonder Lab, it was closed. Big disappointment. I had checked the hours, had only read that it was closed mondays.

We ate at John's before seeing Rock of Ages at the Helen Hayes Theatre/ Pizza was quite good actually, and reasonably priced.

Rock of Ages was great. We had great seats, first row on the Mezz, with nobody sitting in front of us.

Caught the bus at 6:30pm, and left for Montreal.

All in all, we had fun........didn't get to see everything we wanted.

Best advice........get a Metrocard, dress for the weather.

17 replies
NY
posts: 368
1. Re: Just got back..........

it is very strange that the cab driver would not take you. Hilton garden inn is a decent ride from Port Authority, so he was not dropping you because $ were too low. Perhaps he really did not have a clue as to location.

Likely he did not know where on 6th avenue this address was (6th ave runs for miles) but even then: anyone who's been in NY for a little while would know that number 39 is pretty much as far south as can be.

Reminds me of the cab I took once, where the driver asked me to guide him because he had never heard of canal street and of the west side highway. Seems like you were not lucky on this one.

Dublin...
posts: 494
reviews: 6
2. Re: Just got back..........

Enjoyed your report. I remember your Brooklyn Flea and other questions before your trip, glad you enjoyed. I like Balthazar, but have only had dinner there, would prefer to overpay for steak than pancakes!

As an aside, how long is the bus trip from Montreal to New York?

New York...
posts: 16,420
reviews: 30
3. Re: Just got back..........
Destination Expert   What's this?
for Yucatan Peninsula

nice report - thanks.

Those pupusas are great - arent they? It's tempting to schlep to Brooklyn just for a couple of them.

Did you say "Avenue of the Americas" by any chance to the cab driver? I wouldnt know where most hotels are located (either do they) but 39 6th Avenue should have registered. Then again, I have no clue where 6th Avenue starts, but I would think a driver would. A cab driver new to the city, or for whom English is a 2nd language might not have understood that many words.

suitcaseready.com

Montreal
posts: 211
reviews: 7
4. Re: Just got back..........

@mmmmpppp........He was the only taxi driver that gave us a hard time. Maybe he was a newbie. lol

@LMC95.......It was so easy to get to Brooklyn, I shouldn't have worried. Got off at Atlantic station,and literally crossed the street to the flea market. Agree with you, re overpriced food.

As for the trip back home.............If there are no delays at the border or multiple stops, aprox 8 hours. We took the overnight bus, so we got to sleep a bit.

Montreal
posts: 211
reviews: 7
5. Re: Just got back..........

@evening.........ur welcome. Yes, definitely worth the schlep!!

When I gave him the addy, said 39 avenue of the americas, Hilton Garden Inn. When he asked me for the cross st, I said I wasn't sure, and repeated the addy, adding that the hotel was in TRIBECA. He must have asked me for the cross st 3 times. I answered that I thought it was near Canal st, but not sure. And then then he just refused to continue, and stopped the taxi.

It was the strangest thing. We had a good laugh about it.

New York
posts: 11,375
reviews: 10
6. Re: Just got back..........

You really do need to have the cross street - many taxi drivers will simply not know by the number of the address; just a fact.

Lesson learned - something for prospective visitors to take of: be sure to have the cross streets whenever and wherever taking a taxi.

New York...
posts: 62,269
reviews: 2
7. Re: Just got back..........
Destination Expert   What's this?
for New York City

Sounds like a fun trip. I have to ask though, do none of you have a smart phone where you could have looked up the address online? In the end, you did better on the subway, but not a fun way to start the weekend. Thanks for the fun report. What kinds of things did you get at the flea market?

Montreal
posts: 211
reviews: 7
8. Re: Just got back..........

@MomCat1992..........u r right, much easier when you know the cross street. Having said that, it is not impossible without one either. We took a taxi a couple of other times, and driver got us to our destination without a problem, and without delay.

(As a side note, when taking a taxi in Montreal, address is more important than cross street, as you want to be dropped off in front of your intended stop rather than the corner.)

Montreal
posts: 211
reviews: 7
9. Re: Just got back..........

@NYWhiz.......we left the phone at home!!!

Subway was fairly easy to navigate.........uptown/downtown is important to remember. When we asked for directions on the subway, always got a helpful response.

I bought beautiful picture frames, daughter bought old albums, and jewelry, and my son bought an antique lighter made from a bullet(WW1).

I think I might return in the summer when the flea goes outdoors!!

Sydney...
posts: 279
reviews: 12
10. Re: Just got back..........

Love your TR, didnt know about the flea market, so I have now noted it.

Can you please tell me what these are:

I ate a Puposa with cheese and cod!!!!!!!!, as well as a Mac'Cheese Lobster roll!!!!!

many thanks

Karen

Reply to: Just got back..........
Get notified by e-mail when a reply is posted
Preview