We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox. Mac: Safari.

New York City

Free Newsletter

Interested in New York City?

We'll send you updates with the latest deals, reviews and articles for New York City each week.

New York City Forum: Trip report - Easter Weekend 2011

Which New York City hotels are on sale?
See hotels
Atlanta...
posts: 669
reviews: 7
 Trip report - Easter Weekend 2011 

My wife and I recently returned from 4 days in New York, and I am afraid if I don't start writing this trip report now then I will forget everything we did (which was a lot!). As usual, I owe some major props to all the good folks on this forum, who answered not only my specific questions, but other peoples' as well - this made planning for this trip *so* much easier.

The main reason for this visit was a belated 30th wedding anniversary "mystery" trip for my wife and me. For a variety of reasons we were not able to go anywhere special on our actual anniversary (which was earlier this year), so I put this together on short notice to take advantage of some scheduled time off from work right before the Easter weekend. It was a mystery in the sense that my wife knew we were going somewhere, but not the exact destination until we got to the Atlanta airport to depart.

We had each been to New York once before - me for a one day business trip in the mid-1980s, and my wife on a short sight-seeing trip with some relatives in the early 1970s. On my previous trip, I only got about 30 minutes to wander around Rockefeller Plaza. My wife had seen a little more on hers - Empire State Building, The Met, etc. So everything would be new (or "new again"!) for both of us this time around.

A word of warning - my trip reports tend to be long and incredibly detailed, so if you don't like long postings then you might want to skip this. Some people like to read them though, and it helps me relive the experience and sort of "solidify" things in my memory.

So here we go!

-JimG

40 replies
Atlanta...
posts: 669
reviews: 7
1. Re: Trip report - Easter Weekend 2011

Day 1 - "Getting There is *Not* Half the Fun"

I don't usually write much about travel and flight details, but this trip had some interesting moments (and its "only bandwidth"), so what the heck ...

I had booked our departing flight from Atlanta for Wednesday evening at 7:40 PM. I get off work at 3:00 PM each day and my wife leaves her office at 4:00 PM, so we had "mostly" packed the night before to make sure we had time to get to the airport. We live near public transportation (MARTA train) that goes directly to the terminal and don't normally check bags, so can usually leave our house as late as 2-2.5 hours before departure and still get to the gate in plenty of time. This non-stop flight was scheduled to land in New York just after 10:00 PM (at La Guardia), so that would still give us a little time to do some exploring after we arrived.

As I was leaving my office I got an E-mail alert that our flight was delayed until 8:25 - still not too bad, and took some of the time pressure off. It's funny - I had waffled between the 7:40 flight and a later one at 8:50 (which would also be delayed by a similar amount), and was now glad I had chosen the earlier flight even though the timing was a little tighter. My wife arrived home shortly after I did, so we did our last minute packing and hopped in the car to head to the MARTA train station.

I stopped at a drive-through ATM a few miles from the house to get some cash, whereupon I realized that I had left my cell phone charging at home. No worries since we had plenty of time due to the delays, so we headed back home to pick it up. Upon arriving back at the house, I was greeted with a second E-mail alert telling me the flight was delayed even further, until almost 9:00 PM (which would put as at La Guardia around 11:30 PM). I was not real happy about that, but not much I could do.

The train ride to the airport was uneventful, and we actually got there with enough time to relax and have a sit-down meal at one of the restaurants in the terminal (something we are almost never able to do before a flight). When we got to the gate, we learned that the reason for the delay was due to bad weather in the northeast, where the plane was originating. I used the extra time to call the car service and hotel in New York to let them know that we would be arriving later than expected.

The flight up was very smooth - I had selected window seats on the left side of the plane, hoping to catch a glimpse of the Manhattan skyline at night. We were not disappointed, and as the plane made its initial approach (right along the BQE), we had a panoramic view of Manhattan in the clear night air. All the major landmarks were visible and easily identifiable - Statue of Liberty, Brooklyn and Manhattan Bridges, Empire State and Chrysler Buildings, United Nations, etc. It was almost as though we could see every individual light in the skyline - absolutely stunning.

We deplaned right on (delayed) time at Gate 2 in the Delta terminal, whereupon I called the car service to let them know we were ready to be picked up. As we were walking through baggage claim, we were approached by numerous individuals asking us if we "needed a ride". Even without the cautions from the TA forum, I could tell these were not reputable offers, and was glad we had arranged for transport in advance. Based on numerous recommendations (and the fact that I found a coupon on-line!), I had chosen Dial 7, and within a few minutes the driver pulled up in the (very congested) limo area just outside the terminal. We quickly loaded the bags and were off to Manhattan!

The driver took us into the city via the Midtown Tunnel and drove us directly to the hotel (the Millenium Broadway near Times Square). We had selected the Millenium based on tips and recommendations from this forum, plus the fact that they were running a Travel Zoo promotion during our dates, for about $200 a night plus tax. The check-in process went smoothly, and we were given a north-facing room on the 46th (out of 50) floor. The room was spacious enough with floor-to-ceiling windows (that actually opened a crack for some fresh air), and a large-ish bathroom. We had a direct view of St Mary the Virgin Church on W 46th St, and could just see the "GE" letters at 30 Rock to the northeast. Directly to the west, the large Kodak sign in front of the Marriott Marquis at Times Square was clearly visible, along with pedestrians milling about in the "the city that never sleeps". Even though it was almost midnight, we still wanted to do a little exploring, so we dropped the bags in the room and headed out to walk around in Times Square.

It was only about a half block walk from the Millenium Broadway, and the area was congested even though it was a weeknight. It was still fun to see all the lights, the spot where they do the New Year's Eve ball drop, etc. The area around the hotel is also well situated for transportation on the subway by virtue of being only 2-3 blocks from three stations with express service - Times Square, Bryant Park, and Rockefeller Center. The Times Square station is most convenient, with an entrance at W 43rd and Broadway - just west of and across the street from the south side of the hotel. This entrance is closed late at night however, so we walked over to the main station entrance on W 42nd, where we bought a pair of 7 day Metro cards ($29 each) from one of the kiosks. This is absolutely the best deal going if you are planning to be in the city for more than 3-4 days, and we definitely got our money's worth from these passes. The cards can be used for unlimited rides on any MTA bus or for entrance to any subway station, and there are no worries about transfers, reloading the cards, or making mistakes and having to double back and pay again (which thankfully we did not do much of!).

Well of course now that we had the Metro cards we had to try them out. I had heard horror stories about tourists having difficulty mastering the "subway swipe", but we had no trouble at all - just had to make sure the card is not oriented the wrong way (a mistake you will only make once!). I just watched the people ahead of me in line to see how they did it. The cards worked perfectly, and so we ventured into the bowels of the New York Subway for the first time. We decided to start with something simple and took a short ride over to Grand Central Terminal. Unfortunately we were too late to catch the Shuttle (which does not run late nights), so hopped on the 7 train to get there. Not unexpectedly, a lot of other folks had the same idea, and we actually had standing room only on the train (at midnight on a Wednesday!).

After a short ride (and one stop at 5th Ave) we arrived at Grand Central, where we headed topside to Lexington and E 42nd to see the Chrysler Bldg. For some reason I am absolutely fascinated by this particular NY landmark, and probably took more pictures of it than anything else we saw. Of course the lobby was closed (something to save for in the morning!), but we walked up Lexington Ave for a bit to try and get a good night view of the Chysler's distinctive peaked roof. Along the way I spotted a Crumbs Bake Shop, and having heard how good their cupcakes are, made a mental note to stop there for breakfast the next morning.

From there we ducked back into Grand Central via the entrance adjacent to the Graybar building, and then walked around a bit in the main concourse. Even at 1:00 AM there were quite a few people there, although I was sure rush hours were much more crowded! Finally we headed back to the subway platform to go back to the hotel. As we were standing there, a couple walked up and asked me for directions (on my first night in New York, and my first time riding the subway!). I just had to chuckle, as this kind of thing happens to me all the time - I must just look like someone who knows where they are going. Funny thing is that I actually knew the answer to their question - they had come over from Times Square on the Shuttle and were now trying to get back on the 7, and were not sure they were in the right place. Suddenly feeling like an expert, I assured them they were on the correct platform, and that the train would be along shortly. The funniest thing was that this would not be the only time I helped someone with subway directions during this trip!

After a couple of minutes the 7 train rumbled in, and we reluctantly boarded to make our way back to the hotel to try and get some rest. Thursday was going to be a big day, and we wanted to make sure we were ready for it.

-JimG

2. Re: Trip report - Easter Weekend 2011

I am really enjoying how detailed your trip report is & am looking forward to reading about your daily adventures.

Fairhaven...
posts: 1,102
reviews: 50
3. Re: Trip report - Easter Weekend 2011
Destination Expert   What's this?
for New Bedford

Looking forward to the rest.

Boston
posts: 9,908
reviews: 11
4. Re: Trip report - Easter Weekend 2011
Destination Expert   What's this?
for Boston

Great start so far.

Atlanta...
posts: 669
reviews: 7
5. Re: Trip report - Easter Weekend 2011

Day 2 AM - "The Three R's - Rockefeller, Roosevelt, and Riding the Subway"

In spite of our late night excursion the previous evening, by Thursday morning my wife and I were up at 7:00 AM, eagerly preparing for our first full day of sightseeing. The weather forecast for the next few days was sunny and clear for Thursday, cloudy Friday, rain on Saturday, and then clearing on Easter Sunday. We had therefore decided to try and get most of the outdoor activities out of the way early to take advantage of the nicer weather.

Here's some background on our particular travel style (or lack of it!) in case any of you are curious - we are both in our early to mid 50s, and are very active and "outdoorsy". As you will no doubt discover from this trip report, we love to walk and discover things on our own. I personally don't care much for organized tours because they always make me feel rushed, and very often include things that normal tourists like but that I don't find particularly interesting or appealing - probably because I am not "normal" :-). Consequently, we usually do our own research and plan our own trips, based on stuff that *we* like. Those plans tend to be very loose when it comes to sight-seeing, and we always like to allow time to take advantage of things that happen "in the moment". As a result, flexibility and adaptability are always key elements of any traveling that we do.

So our day's itinerary (such as it was) was to wander around midtown Manhattan, visiting a few particular sites of interest, and possibly discovering a few new ones along the way. I had booked us on a Classic Harbor Lines sunset cruise that departed from Chelsea Piers at 6:30 that evening, so with no more specific plans than "be at the docks by 6:00 PM", we set out to see what we could discover.

We retraced our short subway excursion to Grand Central from Wednesday night, but with a few minor changes. Instead of entering Times Square station at the main entrance, we used the W 43rd St entrance, which comes into the station right by the Shuttle tracks. From there we took the Shuttle to Grand Central, and then exited again onto Lexington at E 42nd. This is directly across the street from the Chrysler Building, so we made a quick detour over there to walk through the lobby (which is as far as you can get unless you work there) and then headed up Lexington Ave to grab some breakfast at the Crumbs Bake Shop that we had spotted the night before. My wife ordered a Red Velvet (which is apparently a popular choice) and I had an Artie Lange, plus some coffee. I know a lot of New Yorkers like to eat on the run, but we decided to sit "leisure like" in the bakery (at a table by the window) and watch the world go by.

Following this massive infusion of sugar and caffeine (breakfast of champions!) we went back into Grand Central, where we hopped aboard the 6 train to E 51st St. From there we walked west towards Rockefeller Plaza via E 50th, stopping along the way to admire St Bartholomew's and St Patrick's. Both churches are undergoing exterior renovations and were surrounded by a construction perimeter, but were nevertheless impressive to look at. We considered going into St Patrick's to see the interior but elected to skip that, figuring it might be a better activity for Saturday if the weather was not so cooperative.

After a short walk from the subway station we arrived at Rockefeller Plaza, where I went to purchase tickets to Top of the Rock while my wife watched people skating at the ice rink. I know that folks usually recommend to pre-purchase these tickets, but that was not practical for us since the tickets are timed and we weren't sure exactly when we would be there. Also I have a "rule" on trips where I try never to schedule more than one timed event per day, and usually reserve that for first thing in the morning or last thing at night (again, that whole "flexibility" thing).

Fortunately the line moved pretty quickly, so it did not take long. There was a young British couple directly ahead of me who upon completing their purchase, handed me a pair of discount coupons for $2 off the regular admission. Apparently they had bought some sort of combo pass that could not be combined with the coupons, so instead of just throwing them away they gave them to me. Once again, my procrastination paid off (not the first nor last time that would happen on this trip!). Our admission for TOTR was not for another hour or so, so we used that time to look around in some of the shops in the plaza. In particular there was the Metropolitan Museum of Art shop, a Lego store (which sounds cool but was not really that interesting), and then a quirky little knick-knack shop on W 50th St across from Radio City Music Hall, right by the entrance to the Observation Deck (Pylones - my wife really liked this one).

Eventually the time came for us to head up to TOTR, so we got in the line for the security checks and then the elevators. That all went smoothly except that I forgot to take my spare eyeglasses out of my pocket, so had to be "wanded" at the checkpoint (thank goodness it was not TSA!). The only other annoyance was waiting in line for the souvenir photos, which they did not explain at first that this was actually optional and you could bypass to go directly to the elevators. The ride up to the top is kind of cool, with a short video presentation that is broadcast onto the glass ceiling of the elevator car.

The views from the top were spectacular - skies were clear and blue, but it was very windy. There are actually two observation platforms. The lower one is a little larger, but is surrounded by glass panels and only offers views in one or two directions. The upper platform is open air and allows unobstructed views in three directions. Central Park and the Empire State Building are both clearly visible, as is the "year" ball atop One Times Square. We took lots of pictures up there, including one of my wife with the Empire State Building growing out of her head (coming soon to a Facebook near you!).

After about an hour we came back downstairs and stopped briefly at the NBC Universal Store on the first floor, where we ID-ed a few T-shirts to purchase before our return home. In particular, they had a Star Trek "red crew shirt" that I just *had* to have (if you are a fan of STTOS, then you will know why), and numerous choices from other NBC series including SNL, Seinfeld, Friends, etc. We didn't have much interest in the studio tour (and it was getting close to lunch time) so we departed 30 Rock for some more sight-seeing fun and a bite to eat.

From Rockefeller Center station, we took the F train to Roosevelt Island, mainly so we could ride the tram back :-). However, the subway station there is pretty interesting as well - unlike most of the stations in Manhattan, it feels very spacious due to its vaulted ceiling, and at over 100 feet below ground is one of the deepest subway stations in New York. It features two huge banks of escalators that carry riders from the platform to street level. I understand it required some effort to build due to funding issues, but the end result is pretty impressive.

Once we got topside, we walked down to the West Rd to get a good view of the 59th St Bridge (the inspiration for Simon and Garfunkel's song "Feelin' Groovy"), and then wandered back towards the other side of the island (which is only a few hundred feet wide) to find a place to eat lunch. Right on Main St by the subway station is a place called the River Walk Grill, and that's where we ended up. They actually had some pretty good hot sandwiches for lunch (which were *huge* - we did not know any better and ordered one each, but could easily have split one between us).

From the River Walk Grill we walked south to the tram station, and were surprised at how many other people we saw in the area. I don't think Roosevelt Island is known as a tourist destination, although there are certainly some touristy type things to see - Lighthouse Park, The Octagon, hospital ruins, etc. Unfortunately we didn't have much time to look around, so just hopped aboard the tram for the ride back (and I'm guessing that's what all the other folks were doing as well, since the tram was FULL!). My wife (who is tiny) somehow managed to squeeze up to the front of the car and got some nice pictures as we were making the crossing. I was off to the side with a less interesting view, but still enjoyed the ride. I did manage to get Yet Another shot of the Chrysler Building though. :-)

Our next destination was Central Park, so we walked the short distance from the tram stop to the Lexington Avenue station on the N-Q-R line, where we caught the R going west. The next stop was the 5th Ave station, which actually has an exit directly into the southeast corner of Central Park. After a quick detour through Grand Army Plaza and by the Pulitzer fountain, we were ready to begin our exploration of Central Park itself.

Next up - a walk in the parks!

-JimG

Australind...
posts: 136
reviews: 43
6. Re: Trip report - Easter Weekend 2011

Great report JimG. I like your approach to travel and the level of detail in the report. Thanks for posting.

Lohja...
posts: 469
reviews: 11
7. Re: Trip report - Easter Weekend 2011

Enjoying your report and all the details! The longer, the better, :).

New York...
posts: 62,269
reviews: 2
8. Re: Trip report - Easter Weekend 2011
Destination Expert   What's this?
for New York City

Great report Jim.

U.S.
posts: 960
reviews: 6
9. Re: Trip report - Easter Weekend 2011

Loving your trip report!

I was looking forward to seeing St. Patricks while we are there at Rockefeller... I didn't know it was undergoing exterior renovation, with construction barriers... Too bad... but now I know.

This is the kind of information/detail that is so great to find here on the TA forum!

Louisville...
posts: 941
reviews: 10
10. Re: Trip report - Easter Weekend 2011

You didnt tell us your wifes reaction to the sort of suprise trip!

Reply to: Trip report - Easter Weekend 2011
Get notified by e-mail when a reply is posted
Preview