The local whitefish was fresh and well prepared. Service was friendly and attentive. Right across fro the harbor so you could see the boats arriving as you ate.
Had lunch on the outdoor deck, nice view of the harbor but lots of flies to deal with. I had a burger, wife had whitefish sandwich, both pretty average. Ordered burger me well, it came out medium rare. No chips or fries come with sandwiches, guess bottom line I was underwhelmed by the experience.
We were visiting Bayfield. Got hungry and visited this place because it got decent reviews, and it was next door. Large sandwich menu, limited diner menu. Disappointing. Had a burger. Nothing out of ordinary. No outdoor tables available, so we sat in stools at a makeshift outdoor bar. Uncomfortable me. Service was good. Prices were average. Been there, done that.
To be honest I'm not a huge fish fry kind of girl but this place was recommended to us by a local and the fish fry we had there was our favorite meal while we were in Bayfield. So good and not greasy or fishy tasting like I've had sometimes. I loved the olive tapenade that was on my salad... More
Enjoyed lunch on the outside deck, facing the marina. We could watch the ferries shuttle back & forth to Madeline Island on a gorgeous sunny day. Of course we had to have whitefish. Although the menu stated that the whitefish is only deep-fried for the sandwich, I requested mine to be broiled and my request was granted. There's nothing like... More
I have been here twice and am blown away by the scenery! Their food was great and they also make great affordable cocktails, which made our visit even sweeter! If I make it back up to Bayfield again Pier Plaza will definitely be on our list of places to visit.
My husband, son and I enjoyed the food here twice in two days. I was surprised that the prices were reasonable considering Bayfield is a vacation destination. My 13-year-old son even ate guacamole which was on his bacon and chicken sandwich. We checked out the Club and Cuban as well as the pork wrap. We had the lava cake, monster... More
We stopped here after the Apostle Island cruise, it's right across the street. The plan was to enjoy more of the fresh fish from the area. It was busy as everyone else from the boat had the same idea, so we took a couple spots at the bar The whitefish sandwich was great, no question, but we were blown away... More
I ended up eating at this resturant twice during my stay. The whitefish mediterranean style with onions, tomatoes, and olives was especially delicious! They have some outside seating overlooking the lake, either at tables or barstools, all with great views of the lake. I really liked this place for the value and quality of the foo. Try the sweet potatoe... More
Stopped in and had the lunch special which was a French Dip sandwich with Potato Wedges. This was the best French Dip sandwich I ever had. Tender, perfectly seasoned Prime Rib on a Ciabatta Roll with Au Jus.... classic, no fancy sauces or other things added...it was perfectly amazing. The potato wedges were home made and delicious as well. I... More
If you own or manage Pier Plaza, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing