This place has fabulous gelato! It is always our dessert place while in Paia. The gelato is made with local products and the staff is always so nice.

This place has fabulous gelato! It is always our dessert place while in Paia. The gelato is made with local products and the staff is always so nice.
What a perfect way to end the evening in Paia! We skipped desert at the restaurant we were eating at to try some of their yummy gelato and weren't disappointed!
I love gelato, and have eaten it in several countries. I was surprised to see it in a little town like Paia, but wow what a nice surprise. The server was friendly, told me all about the flavors and let my husband and me sample several flavors before deciding on our order. I had the cheesecake and scattellio (spelling?). My...
More
Great portions, melted too fast and was messy on cone. Get it in a cup!
...then you will be in heaven with creamy gelato here. I am a lover of anything cold and sweet and this place knocked my socks off. I had the coconut gelato and would have eaten the whole tub if I didn't have to be in a swim suit for this trip! Worth a stop and the calories!!
Loved all the exotic choices, it was so pleasing to find quality gelato that had real fruit in it and so many choices. We stayed in Paia 5 nights and ate here everyday. We never could decide on what to get because we wanted to try everything and our favorite from the day before. The only thing I didnt like...
More
If you are looking for something other than shave ice, this is the place.
This store has many different food items. Some you wouldn't think of. Everybody was very helpful.
One of the best kept secrets on Maui. A small, clean charming hole in the wall with one of the best cups of coffee and fabulous gelato on Maui!! I only wish they were open later so we could grab our late afternoon espresso or after dinner coffee there more often!!
On my last day on Maui, I decided to explore Paia. After looking at a few menus around town, I found this little place, and I'm so glad. The hard working Melissa made me her favorite sandwich-roasted veggies and goat cheese, and some lilikoi-ade. It's creative, delicious, reasonably priced fare, and would be great for a trip down the road...
More
If you own or manage Penguini Gelato, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.
Manage your listing