Cheery, fun restaurant with very good food. Good, friendly service. Very comfortable and relaxed. Not too expensive. More

The smoked chicken enchiladas with goat cheese are heavenly! Excellent margaritas on the rocks or blended. Service is a bit slow. More

I really love the margaritas at San Carlos. SOO good! I have a really hard time trying anything new here because I adore the smoked chicken chimichanga. OH MY! The flavors are amazing. Always great food. We found them to be a part of Restaurant.com so you can get a discount if you buy the certificate. Makes it a bit... More

San Carlos serves up decent Mexican food at an OK price, although higher than Mexican chains, the dishes are prepared fresh, so you get more in what you are paying here. It is located just outside of the main downtown in Bainbridge, so day trippers can walk to it from the ferry (just walk down Winslow Way to Madison, then... More

We love to stop in for a Lime Drop at San Carlos whenever possible. When you can't get a seat in the other smaller restaurants nearby, there is room in the bar at San Carlos. We jokingly call it Northwest Mexican food, but it sure is delicious! Often, San Carlos is the birthday dinner choice for our friends when birthdays... More

Great Menu selection, good margaritas and very tasty food for both of us. No negatives in our visit.... More

Sorry, but after coming here a handful of times, I'm not going back. Have never experienced such expensive prices for such terrible quality, mediocre food. Have come here for atmosphere, which is nice, but food tastes like a Mexican-American chain restuarant fare. Prices were $15-24 an entree and quality was terrible - we've been here when it's dead slow and... More

We moved to Bainbridge Island almost a year ago and live about a block from this restaurant, but drive almost 30 minutes away to get our Mexican food. I love that this is a family owned place, and I love the location and the building. Beyond that I don't have much that is nice to say about this restaurant. The... More

We have eaten here many times but I am finally getting around to writing a review. Great Mexican food. Creative, healthy and a great value. The location is convenient and close to the ferry from Seattle. More