Pizza is just ok. I usually have it delivered and the crust is always soggy. Not my favorite place but husband seems to like it.
This was the best pizza - it was so good and the staff was really nice - made sure we have our drinks refilled and that we like what we order
I'm a pizza aficionado and have very high standards. When I moved to the Hilton Head area 20 years ago I was delighted to find NY City Pizza and would occasionally commute to the island when I wanted great pizza. Super happy that they are now open in Bluffton, 5 minutes from home. Great pizza, service, value and atmosphere!! ++
We paid 40 + bucks for a pizza that was burnt on the bottoms And cold in the center .... How does that even happen? We will not be going back
We had gone here a while back when they first opened and the pizza was just okay and the service was also just okay. Went back on Sunday night because I had a Living Social deal and it was much better. They were running half price appetizers and $1 off the whole bar so our coupon went a really long... More
A bunch of us escaped from a nearby plantation the other night to check out this place and to compare it with a few of the other good places opening up around Bluffton (such as Fiddlehead Pizza). We got there and the place was packed, which is easy to understand since it's not particularly big. So if we actually had... More
Locals like us always went to Upper Crust for pizza on Fri night. We now have a new place! Great pizza, great service from Matt. Yes, it is small, crowded, noisey....which is part of the attraction! Give it a try!
If you own or manage NYC Pizza, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing