We didn't stay at the Inn, we stayed at another associated Inn. However, we found ourselves eating on the porch many times because the food was fabulous, large portions, great varieties and wonderful views of the harbor and good place to people watch!

We went with a large group of friends for dinner and a sunset cocktail. The location and setting is very nice - sitting back in a chair on the sweeping lawn with a drink while watching the sunset was like a scene out of the Great Gatsby. The food was good - nothing to rave about but the setting is... More

We had tapas on the lawn around sunset. The food was just OK (and very pricey), the service was very odd (more about that below), but the sunset was the most amazing I've ever seen in my life!! (And I live on the California coast and have visited Hawaii a number of times, so I've seen a lot of sunsets... More

I do not mind spending money on an excellent meal. I am from NYC so that is par for the course, and when on vacation who cares! However, when the wine your selling is 50% off, and the patron tells you that the wine is turning and tastes bad, do not be insulting. We then ordered a 100 dollar bottle... More

Hunker down in an Adirondack chair on the lawn, grab a drink (seat-side service) and maybe some light snacks and just...deflate.

The Atlantic Inn is in a beautiful location and is a lovely old building. It's downright stately on an island known for its informality. When the food arrives one wishes that the chef would keep it simple but alas it's not that way. Dishes come with too many ingredients combined in ways that a chemist would not recommend. Be prepared... More

I have been lucky to have eaten at the Atlantic several times. Some things never change: the view from the veranda. Spectacular. Drinks and tapas on the veranda before dinner enhance the dining experience. The outstanding servers. The owner sets a high standard for his servers. It works. Dinner in an antique setting, amazing views from all windows and very... More

I don't know how anyone can give a bad review for the Atlantic. It is easily the best restaurant on the Island. Creativity is notable and the Chef was professionally trained at Culinary Institute of America. The servers are informative and are able to answer any questions about your meal. This is not a rushed dining experience, so plan on... More

Best spot for calming down after a busy day.Peaceful view of Crescent Beach in the distance. Can play crochet if you ask inside.