This place is a shack and I mean that in the best way possible. It looks like TripAdvisor features the picture of their prettier cousin in Westhampton. No frills and no fancy pants here! Small counter for pickup and a display of fish as you walk in with a small seating area to the left. We came seeking an inexpensive,... More

Mussels just too small to enjoy. Too expensive for plastic patio furniture atmosphere. Wouldn't go back.

Seriously TripAdvisor get a clue - there are two locations and they are totally different. At the Westhampton location it's upscale and really good. In Riverhead it's not so upscale, but still pretty good. Tonight the hubby and I went to Westhampton and I had one of the top 5 meals of my life there. Pistachio encrusted baso and the... More

My husband and I visited Long Island at the beginning of August. Our host at the Beaver dam Creek House B&B in Westhampton recommended the Bouy One. The food and service were good. Prices were reasonable and portions were ample. During our four day stay, we dined there twice; eating inside once and outside once. If we go back to... More

For a very decent burger and an excellent Cobb Salad loaded with seafood this is your place. Location convenient to visiors to Westhampton Care Center. My choice for lunch when I'm in the area.

the wait staff is very young and inexperienced... you wait forever from beginning to end... and after the dinner , my debit card number was stolen and used at a later date... thank goodness my bank alerted me and shut my account down....I won't be going back there any time soon.

I just had a chance to eat here this weekend and I must say I was pleasantly surprised right from the beginning. The outside of the restaurant was well kept. Once inside you are greeted with open arms. The bar is awesome with someone that knows more than beer. If you are looking for a place to have a cocktail... More

I have been going here for a few years. Everything I have tried I have enjoyed. My husband likes that the fish is fresh. When my children were old enough to experiment we had them try the sweet thai cod fish (can't remember the name of it) and they loved it. Now my 4 year old son will try fish... More

This would qualify as a bottom tier tourist trap where I come from. It is benefiting from inexplicable positive reviews from people who either drink too much or want to fill their kids up because the portions are huge but the food is worse than a chain restaurant.