Stopped by after flying in from a local airport. I am in Montauk ALOT. I almost always eat at Inlet because it's owned by an acquaintance. However this time we didn't have transportation so we walked from the airport and didn't feel like hoofing it all the way to Inlet. Why not try Fishbar? Granted it was a thursday, before... More

We dined at the restaurant during an evening when a local civic club had a meeting in the same room; plenty of staff were on hand, so we didn't mind. Unfortunately, the staff seemed more distracted than busy. A while after our menus were provided, our waiter asked if we'd decided on our choices. I asked if there were any... More

I highly recommend the Jalepeno & Corn Fritters for appetizer and I had Scallops Ceviche and Pan Seared Scallops in jasmine rice! great combination of the scallop with the bacon, tomato and pesto! yup, i'm a sucker for scallops and definitely worth having! I find the price very reasonable imagine i came all the way from a country where scallops... More

Fishbar has an inventive menu--quinoa, scallops w/ bacon, clams w/ chorizo, and even vegetarian choices. They are as fresh as promised, too. While we were there two fishermen came in to see their catches. You'll sit right on the dock and the view is lovely. It definitely wasn't cheap, but we'll go back. More

The Fishbar in Montauk does not seem to be designed as a fine dining establishment but you could fool me. The setting is casual and rustic with mostly simple outside dining adjacent to a operational marina and the Montauk inlet. When you first sit down you don't know exactly what to expect, but you don't really care since the views... More

Far too pricey for what you get. I ordered the fish tacos which was very bland. No punch to the salsa whatsoever, not even sure there was salsa. I saw tomatoes and lettuce. My husband ordered the Tile Fish. He was given a diet portion, maybe 4oz's for $26. Both not worth the money. Although the service was good, and... More

My husband and I use Trip Advisor as our guide when we dine out on vacation. My husband takes great pleasure in spending hours on Trip Advisor to find truly unique and delicious restaurants. Well, I can tell you that this restaurant was so delightful in every way that we have been there 3 times since, and are actually driving... More

My then girl friend (now wife) and I eat out a lot and are often critical and/or disappointed with restaurants not living up to the great reviews on Trip Advisor, but I can tell you that this was not one of those restaurants! I brought my then girl friend here the night I was going to propose and everything was... More

We thought we'd try this new restaurant on the other side of the lake from our hotel. Wow! We were so impressed with the food and atmosphere that we returned for a second night. Located on a dock overlooking the boat harbor beneath an awning. Casual atmosphere... my husband was happy because he could wear his shorts. We each had... More