We attempted to make reservations at Harvest for Saturday evening but by the time we got a hold of the restaurant saturday afternoon they informed us they were booked. However, they have a first come/first serve policy for their outdoor seats. Being as the Montauk Music Festival was in Town we were prepared for a busy restaurant but it was... More

My boyfriend and I dined here last year around Labor Day. The ambiance at this restaurant was soft and romantic. I found the following to be exceptional: the service, quality of the food and portions sizes were a perfect value. I would recommend this restaurant without a doubt. More

I was out in Montauk in early December, and gave Harvest a try. The restaurant was decorated for the holidays, and it was simply stunning. Dinner was delicious, and I couldn't find one thing about the restaurant that was negative. This past weekend, I was out in Montauk again, this time with three teenaged boys. Tried Gosman's new menu (good,... More

Arrived for dinner without a reservation. Well worth the wait as the Martini was excellent. Food was very good and the portions were more than adequate. We had the Ice Cream Sandwich for dessert and it was incredible, order it for two. Service was attentive and not over bearing. Only downside was it tends to get a little noisy. Would... More

very nice setting, food was great but in my opinion prices are too high for our taste, also, drinks i thought were on the weak side, $9 for a mixed drink... please put more alcohol in it, we would go back but we will cut some corners with the menu More

We had many recommendations to go here, so we tried it out on our weekend getaway. We found the food to be very good, portions are from normal sized to generous (we ordered only half plates, as they serve family style) pricing is high, however. We had the calamari salad, which is very popular. It is fried calamari mixed into... More

The Harvest restaurant offers delicious food in a lovely setting. Seafood is great, lamb ok. The service is efficient, but not overly attentive. Do not go without a reservation and strive for waterfront dining in order to catch the sunset. It does tend to get loud and too crowded. More

Have been going for years and it always works. Simple straight forward menu. Low key ambiance even with full house - the very low lighting seems to dial things back. The swordfish is excellent but I have recently switched off it (a little late I confess) because it's overfished and equally as important it is fished using a long line... More

I knew when the first reservation available wasn't until almost 9PM that this place was popular, even though it is off season. I am glad I waited. My daughters each got a very reasonably priced prix fix special, and loved it. I don't like what they eat, and ordered salmon with risotto. It was probably the best piece of grilled... More