I did not find what other reviewers found, in that the service was poor and the food, while not terrible, was nothing to write home about. Overall, the value wasn't there, as the dishes come down on the high price side with small portions. Fool me once..... More

the dishes are wonderful, different, extremely tasty and the service is perfect. Fish dishes are just awesome and the appetizers interesting! nice alcoholic beverage menu too! Very pretty views on the pond. More

We had 2 delicious meals at reasonable prices. Lovely casual atmosphere....very classy. Excellent service. We had eaten there once before, 2 years ago. Consistently great! More

Ate here on Tues 10/25. Started w/ a trio sampler of dumpling, tomato soup & beet salad (all were good) 2nd course was a chopped salad (Not remarkable too much dressing) next time I'll get something different. Entree was blowfish(tails)I've caught many but never ate it. It was dry but not fishy, the sauce was good. Dessert was coconut bread... More

Outstanding American fare from the owners of the equally excellent Harvest on Fort Pond. One of the best restaurants on Long Island. More

Be sure to go for the prix fixe menu $15 for 3 wonderful courses! More

We have had dinner at East by Northeast every trip to Montauk and the food and service are consistently excellent. Exceptionally beautiful before dark with an expansive view overlooking Fort Pond. More

My husband, 4 year old son, and I ate here last week based on a recommendation from a friend. We were not disappointed! The service was spot on, our food was delicious and prepared exactly how we asked, and the drinks were yummy! East by Northeast should be rated much higher than 28th! More

The restaurant decor was well done and the staff could not be friendlier. We loved that far wall of the restaurant was all windows and that there was the most beautiful tree just outside our window seat. The food was expensive, but delicious. In fact, everything was well prepared, well cooked, well seasoned and memorable. This is a definite must... More