Wonderful ice cream in the middle of nowhere (OK, near Interlaken). My favorite is the gianduia, hazelnut chocolate, but all of the flavors I've tried have been great. Some ice cream is just sweet and bland, but these flavors are not just creative, they actually taste like what they're supposed to.They also make a wide array of wine sorbets, perfect... More

a must stop for ice cream lovers passing by on rt96 More

A little place out in the country, north of Ithaca, that can't be missed! When you are out visiting the area(stopping at wineries, etc) do not miss this gem! The best ice cream I have ever had! Innovative flavors as well as more traditional ones. Nice food choices; delicious coffees too. More

We stopped at Cayuga Lake Creamery for the first time this past weekend. Very impressed... The ice cream flavors were great! Will definitely return again when in the area. More

Cayuga creamery has the most creamy ice cream, much better than purity. The flavors are all amazing and very strong, reminding me a little of gelatos in Italy. The waffle cones are amazing and the freshest (you watch them made right in front of you!) When you walk into the shop, you smell the amazing waffle smell. The sundae choices... More

Even though it was late October and the temperature was dipping into the low 40s, this ice cream brought the taste of summer back to Cayuga Lake. The cake batter supreme ice cream (cake batter ice cream with fudge swirls) and the sea salt and caramel ice cream were both extremely delicious and quenched our sweet tooth. In addition to... More

This is our all-time favorite ice cream place. The portions are HUGE, they let you split single scoops (half cookie dough, half cake batter supreme, mmmm!), and give you samples of their more creative flavors if you ask. The owners design their own flavors, and come up with some really interesting mixes. For the price, it's the best value of... More

This is a well-run place along a beautiful highway in the Finger Lakes. The ice cream is divine, the staff is patient and respectful, and the setting is relaxing. I've been 2x and had the same flavor both times since I thought it was so good that I can't bring myself to try others. It's the chocolate/hazelnut ice cream (I... More

I often ride my bicycle 37 miles round trip to Cayuga Lake Creamery. It's that good. Last week I went 3 times and I meet people from all over the area who travel there just for the ice cream. More