There are a few places to eat in the tiny hamlet of Indian Lake, but this is the best place. There is a huge menu of eclectic foods, and very basic stuff---a great enough variety to make everyone in the family happy. Good bar drinks too. There is a big wood bar to sit at if you just want a... More

I was visiting my cousin & his wife who have a camp near Indian Lake. We sat around chatting and didn´t get out to look for a place to have dinner until after 7 p.m. It was the Thursday night preceding the Colombus Day weekend & the Indian Lake Restaurant & Tavern was jammed. After a short wait, the owner... More

We ate here twice during our short stay at Blue Mountain Lake and you can see it's a favorite among the locals which is always a good sign! The food is very good homecookin' and the servers are most attentive. We asked for ice cream which they didn't have so our waitress told us about a place just down the... More

My husband and I went for lunch. The place didn't look great but the chili con carne was fabulous and the best french fries. Everything was good and we can't wait to go back. More

My husband and I are taking a leisurely trip through upstate New York and stayed at Binder's Cabins in the Adirondacks at Indian Lake. They recommended the Indian Lake Restaurant and Tavern. We had a good dinner there last night and enjoyed the food and the service. It was a pleasant and tasty. More

As recommended by our innkeeper, we headed to Indian Lake Restaurant for dinner right after we arrived. We were really hungry, so started with the crab cakes, which were very crab-by, no fillers, very yummy. I bravely ordered the seared ahi tuna with sesame seeds and was not disappointed - it was nicely cooked and very fresh. My husband tried... More

Indian Lake restaurant really impressed with a wide menu, reasonable prices, and friendly service. I loved the chili, which really benefited from being spiked with tequila and featured juicy steak chunks. The salads were fresh and delicious and the burgers and fries well above average. My wife and I came back here again and again during our week in the... More

When we booked a cottage for a weeks vacation in Indian Lake, we did not have very high culinarry expectations bearing in mind what a small place it is. However, one visit to the Indian Lake Restaurant and Tavern and all that changed. This place is a real gem. Not only the quality of the food and service were excellent,... More

Most of the Adirondacks seem to be back in 1982 as far as originality and nutritional thinking. You're mainly stuck with burgers, pizza and assorted fried foods. The Indian Lake Restaurant and Tavern is different. It was so much better than everything else around we kept coming back. And even if you just get their burgers, they're great burgers and... More