Clams over cooked lunch menu outside ask for it was told weare serving dinner ,my wife who is vegertarian orders eggplant parm. 18.oo dollars she was not a happy camper! Two party's were in progress at this time ,they were udrddstaffed in my option,waitress gave me credit slip to sign,With ball point pen ,bright yellow advertising past control company! Pointed... More

The mark of Hurricane Sandy remains on a rebuilding City Island. Another venue had to be found for a post training luncheon on or near City Island and I recommended to the person chairing that they go to Artie's. I have been there many times over the years and was never disappointed. Well, we weren't this time either. PP price... More

Excellent food at reasonable prices considering the excellent qiality and ample portions. Service was prompt and courteous staff. Can't wait to go back.

This is my go to spot. Never had a bad incident and always liked the food.the pasta dishes are plentiful the surf and turf is pretty good too. If you like Clam Chowder this is your spot. The service has always been fine, I have been going here for years. If I want a decent meal where I definitely did... More

My wife and I were on City Island at about 1PM and decided to stop for lunch. Not being seafood lovers we saw a Zagat rating sign at the front door of Artie's and decided to go in. That's where our mistakes started. We sat down and were given diner menus. When we asked about lunch menus the waiter gave... More

My husband and I really enjoy coming here when we visit family in the Bronx. We always order the cold antipasto platter and clams casino as an appetizer. My husband's lamb entree was awesome; cooked perfectly and a very generous portion. My baked ziti was surprisingly disappointing, though. The sauce was just average, although the portion size was tremendous. Waitstaff... More

this place has been around forever--great italian/seafood fair--on the expensive side but worth it--known for their lobster so order that if it's your 1st time there--they also have a good bar if you just want drinks and something to nosh on

W ent to this restaurant on the first Friday in November with a friend. I ordered eggplant parmesan with French fries. The eggplant was a mushy tasteless, ersatz Italian mess. Obviously microwaved from a long frozen state. My friend's fish was not fresh and no better than Gorton's or Mrs. Paul's from supermarket .

I have been dining at City Island for about 15years, I have to say, Artie's never disappoints. My husband is not a big seafood lover like I am and he also loves the food, their lamb chops are always his favorites there. I love their Italian & seafood menu, truly the best of both worlds. Their king crab legs are... More