We have dined at this restaurant several times. The food is average as it seems to be very inconsistent. One time I had a fish dinner and it was outstanding....great in fact. The next time, when I cut into it, it appeared to have water "shooting" out of it and it was wet and soggy on the underside instead of... More

Well, first of all you have to find the restaurant. The restaurant is down a sketchy looking road and their signs are not very helpful. After I arrived I could tell this was not the cleanest looking restaurant I've been to but I decided to continue on my journey. The interior is pretty cheesy then again, a lot of restaurants... More

To cubiclewarrior who said the dining arear was filthy, that was an out and out lie. We have been there many, many times. The dining area is always clean. They do have an outside seating are that can be used in the summer. Their food has always been good. Are you sure this is the Restaurant you went to? More

My husband and I have eaten at Fisher Bay on numerous occasions and have never received a bad meal. The pizza is my favorite, but there are other great dishes like chicken parmesan and crab stuffed haddock that also top my list. The atmosphere is casual and the view of Oneida Lake, the friendly staff, and of course, the food... More

We live on Oneida Lake and this is a perfect place to go by boat....there are no home cooking restaurants between Brewerton and Sylvan that you can go to like this. Owners really care about the place and are always there to oversee it. We usually sit outdoors in the summer and there's a nice view from the deck facing... More

Small, clean dining room. Had a great view. Service was fast and the food was good. Stop in after a day of snowmobiling! More

Fisher Bay Restaurant is tucked away on Barrett Lane on the shores of Onieda Lake in Upstate NY. It's an old family place, complete with a bar full of regulars and an extensive jukebox. Great place to get some wings, munchies and have a drink while playing some pool - but it's also a nice place to get a good... More

I had a BLT and sweet potato fries... the bread was stale and the fries were soggy. My husbands scallops weren't as bad as my meal, though they were served IN a bowl of butter. I didn't see an outdoor seating area, but maybe that would make it more tolerable, as the dining room was filthy. More

Great Chicken Wings!! More